It appears you have not registered with our community. To register please click here ...

!!

Welcome to Russian Women Discussion - the most informative site for all things related to serious long-term relationships and marriage to a partner from the Former Soviet Union countries!

Please register (it's free!) to gain full access to the many features and benefits of the site. Welcome!

+-

Author Topic: Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29  (Read 5468 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Adel

  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 65
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« on: February 23, 2006, 08:50:12 PM »
 Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29

 February 23, 2006, 8:14 PM

MOSCOW, February 23 (RIA Novosti) - A total of 49 people, were killed, and 29 injured after the roof of the Basmanny market in downtown Moscow partly collapsed early in the morning, an emergency ministry spokesman said Thursday.
Yury Sedelnikov, the head of the Emergency Situations Ministry Moscow department, said the rescue operation was nearly over. "The whole facility has been searched. No more dead bodies have been found yet, and we hope no more [dead bodies] will be discovered," he said.
Earlier, some ministry officials put the death toll at 50.
President Vladimir Putin said the incident should be thoroughly investigated.
Emergency Situations Minister Sergei Shoigu heads the rescue operation, which involves some 500 rescuers. He said the collapse of some 13,000 square meters of the roof had probably been caused by a construction defect.
Andrei Legoshin, a ministry official, said the market roof collapse resembled a similar tragedy in Transvaal Park building in Moscow that collapsed two years ago killing 28 and injuring more than 100. Transvaal Park was designed by the same architect as the Basmanny market - Nodar Kancheli.
Legoshin said some 60% of the debris had been cleared as of 19.00 Moscow time (4 p.m. GMT). He did not rule out some more bodies or survivors could be found under the rubble.
Moscow mayor Yury Luzhkov, who arrived at the site of the tragedy that mainly affected non-Muscovites, told journalists that the roof collapse had not been a terrorist act. He said it could have been caused by heavy load of snow accumulated on top of the building. "The possible cause [of the collapse] is the excessive amount of snow gathered on the roof, which has a concave shape," the mayor said. However, he said the load on the roof had been within the prescribed limits.
He confirmed that after a tragedy at Transvaal Park in February 2004, all buildings designed by architect Nodar Kancheli had been inspected. The roof of the Basmanny market was designed to support heavy loads of snow and had special drainage systems, the mayor said.
Luzhkov said all buildings in Moscow with similar roofs should be inspected once again.
A criminal case was opened on the incident.
After being interrogated by the investigators in connection with the incident, architect Kancheli said it had occurred due to improper maintenance: many kiosks had been mounted on the entresol along the whole perimeter of the market, and the construction had not been designed for such additional load. He also said the accident could have been caused by excessive amount of snow. He added that the building had been opened in 1975.
The Moscow firefighting service said a small fire had occurred under the debris of the Basmanny market after the collapse, but that it had been put out and no one was hurt in the flame.


 February 23, 2006, 5:17 PM

MOSCOW, February 23 (RIA Novosti) - Investigators interrogated Thursday an architect who designed the Basmanny market building in central Moscow after a tragic accident that had killed 47 and injured 29 people so far, a prosecutor's office official said.
"He was questioned in connection with the investigation," the official said referring to Nodar Kancheli, who also designed the Transvaal Park building in the capital that collapsed on February 14, 2004 killing 28 people.
"We are planning to interrogate him in the future depending on the results of further investigation," the official said.
The architect said the accident could have been caused by improper maintenance of the building or by excessive amount of snow on its roof
« Last Edit: February 23, 2006, 08:51:00 PM by Adel »

Offline Bruce

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1509
  • Country: 00
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Russia
  • Status: Married 5-10 years
  • Trips: > 10
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« Reply #1 on: February 24, 2006, 10:10:05 AM »
Nodar Kancheli - Now what are the other buildings this guy designed in Moscow?  Remind me to stay clear of them.
"A word is dead when it is said, some say.  I say it just begins to live that day."  Emily Dickinson

Offline Bruno

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3926
  • Gender: Male
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« Reply #2 on: February 24, 2006, 11:02:46 AM »
Quote from: Bruce
Nodar Kancheli - Now what are the other buildings this guy designed in Moscow?  Remind me to stay clear of them.
- Building of Council of Ministers of Russian Federation.
- House of The Government in Sukhumi
- Baumanski Market in Moscow
- Hip roof of Voskresenski Church rotunda in New Jerusalem.
- Savior Church ( Cupola and Central Vault)
- Belgrade I and Belgrade II in Moscow
- TV Center in Moscow
- High-rise buildings in Tashkent
- Vault of Circus studio
- Health Resort Complex "Druzhba" in Yalta
- "Microbioprom " Sanatorium in Yalta
- "Ukraine" Sanatorium building in Yalta
- Supporting structures of the Trade Complex frame in Manezhnaya Square
- Light-transmitting roof over the Atrium of the Old Arcade
- Sport Palace in Toliatti
- Hotel-business center on Novinski avenue ( in the prosess construction)
- Inhabited complex on Veernaya street.
- Drinking Gallery in Essentuki
- Dining-room in Tbilissi

project :

- Automuseum in Toliatti
- Slipway in Sukhumi
- Sanatorium for 700 beds in Dgermuk city
(in the process of the  construction)
- Roof over the summer theatre in Vite
- Cover of a skating ring in Toliatti
- Special Sanatorium in Yalta ( in the process of the construction)
- Public cultural center "Sphere"
- Roof over the Olympic Stadium in Berlin

http://www.archcenter.org/eng/who/default.asp?action=show&cid=1&id=232

Offline Adel

  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 65
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« Reply #3 on: February 24, 2006, 03:46:59 PM »
 
Death toll in Moscow market roof collapse reaches 57, including 1 child





 

« Last Edit: February 24, 2006, 04:40:00 PM by Adel »

Offline Adel

  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 65
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« Reply #4 on: February 24, 2006, 10:54:22 PM »
Director of collapsed Moscow market detained

 

MOSCOW, February 24 (RIA Novosti) - The director of a Moscow market where the roof collapsed Thursday, killing at least 58 people and injuring more than 30 others, has been detained, the city prosecutor's office said Friday.
"The market's director, Mark Mishiyev, has been detained as a suspect," a spokesman for the office said.
The bodies of 57 people were recovered from the wreckage of Moscow's Basmanny market Thursday after its roof caved in early in the morning and one person died of injuries on Friday, the Emergency Situations Ministry said

Offline Adel

  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 65
Moscow market roof collapse kills 49, injures 29
« Reply #5 on: February 25, 2006, 01:51:38 PM »
[align=left]



[align=right]Sergei Grits / AP[/align]
A view of the Basmanny market Friday. Workers using heavy machinery dug through the rubble and removed sections of the roof in hopes of finding survivors.[/align]


Investigators are focusing on whether a design flaw or poor maintenance caused the roof of the Basmanny food market to collapse in east central Moscow last week, killing at least 66 people, mostly Azeri vendors.

The death toll could rise further, as emergency workers continued the search for bodies Saturday. The latest body was pulled from the rubble at 5:20 p.m.

About 150 vendors at the market at 47/1 Ulitsa Baumanskaya were trading at around-the-clock stalls, getting ready for business or sleeping when the roof fell in at 5:27 a.m. Thursday.

The dead included 45 Azeris, eight Georgians, five Tajiks, three Uzbeks, two Russians and one person with dual Russian and Georgian citizenship, Emergency Situations Ministry spokesman Viktor Beltsov told Ekho Moskvy radio on Saturday. Two more bodies remained unidentified.

Twenty-one people were in the hospital on Saturday, 12 in critical condition, the city health department said, Interfax reported.

On Friday, police detained the market's director, Mark Meshiyev, on suspicion of causing death by negligence, Moscow City Prosecutor Anatoly Zuyev said.

Meshiyev had been ordered to improve fire safety at the market two months ago by a Basmanny district prosecutor, Zuyev said, apparently suggesting that the market had a poor maintenance record, Interfax reported.










The roof's architect, Nodar Kancheli, who designed the roof of the Transvaal water park, which caved in and killed 28 people in February 2004, arrived at the scene two hours after the collapse had reduced the market to a heap of rubble.

Kancheli said the market's hubcap-shaped, concave roof was unusual because it was supported by a system of steel ropes rather than pillars. The building was completed in 1977, he said.

"The market was built a long time ago, and the organizations that operated it had to check the condition of the ropes," he said, Interfax reported.

Kancheli said that contrary to the building's design specifications, many vendors had set up stalls on the mezzanine, which was connected to the roof, RIA-Novosti reported.

Prosecutors interrogated Kancheli as part of the investigation on Thursday, said Sergei Marchenko, a spokesman for the city prosecutor's office, Interfax reported.

Vyacheslav Glazychev, a professor at the Moscow Architecture Institute, said the design was not to blame for the collapse.



[align=left]



[align=right]Vladimir Filonov / MT[/align]
A man after escaping the collapse[/align]


"Poor Kancheli! If a building has been up for 30 years, there can be no talk about a design fault," he said, Lenta.ru reported. Poor maintenance was a likely cause of the collapse, Glazychev said.

Mayor Yury Luzhkov, who arrived at the site Thursday, did not rule out poor design or maintenance as causes of the collapse, but said the construction materials used for the roof -- pre-stressed concrete -- could be at fault. Pre-stressed concrete is made by casting concrete over steel strands that are under high tension and therefore are more resistant to downward pressure.

"Such structures apparently require different materials," Luzhkov said, Interfax reported.

The age of the building could also be a reason why the roof fell, Luzhkov said. The roof was designed to withstand snow as thick as 1.4 meters, but measurements indicated that about 40 centimeters of snow was on the roof when it collapsed, Luzhkov said.

Luzhkov said experts had ruled out a terrorist attack, but the City Prosecutor's Office said investigators asked them to study if an explosion had taken place before the roof collapsed.

Up to 300 relatives and friends of vendors came to the market shortly after the first television reports of the collapse Thursday morning and anxiously watched the rescue effort from behind a police cordon on the next street, Baumansky Pereulok.

At about 1 p.m., a weeping man with a bruised nose appeared from behind the police cordon and spoke to a crowd of teary relatives and friends in Azeri.

"He said that all our brothers are dead there!" a woman exclaimed as she wept.

The man, Oktai Salmanov, who had been selling herbs at the market, said his three sisters, who also worked in the market, had been killed.

"Suddenly, everything collapsed. I was near the entrance, and that was how I managed to get out," Salmanov said.

A group of about 50 Azeri men attempted to break through the police cordon after an officer refused to allow a man to go identify a dead relative.

As the crowd received news of each increase in the death toll -- it grew by 10 in two hours Thursday afternoon -- relatives of the victims screamed and burst into tears.

An ambulance medic -- one of 50 that the authorities sent to the scene -- was nearby with sedative pills, water and injections for injuries.

The injured were rushed to hospitals Nos. 29, 36 and 52 and to the Sklifosovsky First Aid Institute.

Yury Akimov, first deputy head of the Emergency Situations Ministry's Moscow branch, said people under the debris were calling from their mobile phones, helping to direct rescuers, Interfax reported. Also, sniffer dogs were pointing rescuers to where people might be, he said.

Six cranes were able to approach the debris and clear large concrete slabs only after rescue workers cut the electric tram wires that blocked the way.



[align=left]



[align=right]Vladimir Filonov / MT[/align]
Emergency Situations Ministry workers covering up the bodies of victims from the market collapse on Thursday.[/align]


Around 5:45 p.m., rescue workers said that there was no hope left of finding anyone alive underneath the collapsed roof. The Emergency Situations Ministry said it stopped looking for survivors on Friday morning.

Azeri Health Minister Oktai Shiraliyev arrived in Moscow on Saturday to arrange for the transportation of Azeri victims' bodies to their native country for burial. He praised Moscow's disaster relief efforts, including the treatment of the injured.

"Everything is being done to the fullest extent and even in excess of it," he told Channel One television after visiting a hospital.

The country's chief epidemiologist, Gennady Onishchenko, said Saturday that workers should not sleep at markets overnight, when markets should be closed. The vendors would not have died if they had complied with this rule, he said, RIA-Novosti reported.

The State Duma faction of the nationalist Rodina party said it intended to ask City Hall for a list of buildings designed by Kancheli because "perhaps all of these buildings ... pose a threat to Muscovites," party leader Dmitry Rogozin said, Interfax reported.

City Hall closed the central Danilovsky market, which has a domed roof, immediately after the Basmanny market collapse on Thursday, and it remained closed Saturday when NTV television showed workers shoveling snow from its roof.

President Vladimir Putin ordered an investigation into the collapse Thursday. "We will have to conduct a thorough investigation and get objective information about the causes," he said.

On Friday, Luzhkov said he expected the cleanup to be completed by Monday, Interfax reported. A new shopping mall will be built on the site of the market, he said.

Luzhkov said Moscow had several other buildings whose roofs were designed by Kancheli.because it was supported by a system of steel ropes rather than pillars. The building was completed in 1977, he said.

"The market was built a long time ago and the organizations that operated it had to check the condition of the ropes," he said, Interfax reported.

Kancheli said that, contrary to the building's design specifications, many vendors had set up stalls on the mezzanine, which was connected to the roof, RIA-Novosti reported.

Prosecutors interrogated Kancheli as part of the investigation on Thursday, said Sergei Marchenko, a spokesman for the city prosecutor's office, Interfax reported.

Vyacheslav Glazychev, a professor at the Moscow Architecture Institute, said the design was not to blame for the collapse.

"Poor Kancheli! If a building has been around for 30 years there can be no talk about a design fault," he said, Lenta.ru reported. Poor maintenance was a likely cause of the collapse, Glazychev said.

Mayor Yury Luzhkov, who arrived at the site Thursday, did not rule out poor design or maintenance as causes of the collapse, but said the construction materials used for the roof - pre-stressed concrete - could be at fault. Pre-stressed concrete is material made by casting concrete over steel strands that are under high tension and therefore are more resistant to downward pressure.

"Such structures apparently require different materials," Luzhkov said, Interfax reported.

The age of the building could also be a reason why the roof fell, Luzhkov said. The roof was designed to withstand snowfalls as thick as 1.4 meters, but measurements indicated that about 40 centimeters of snow was on the roof when it collapsed, Luzhkov said.

Luzhkov said experts had ruled out a terrorist attack, but the city prosecutor's office said investigators asked them to study if an explosion had taken place before the roof collapsed.

Up to 300 relatives and friends of vendors came to the market shortly after the first television reports of the collapse Thursday morning and anxiously watched the rescue effort from behind a police cordon in the next street, Baumansky Pereulok.

At about 1 p.m. a weeping man with a bruised nose appeared from behind the police cordon and spoke to a crowd of teary relatives and friends in Azeri.

"He said that all our brothers are dead there!" a woman exclaimed as she wept.

The man, Oktai Salmanov, who was selling herbs at the market, said that his three sisters, who also worked in the market, were killed.

"Suddenly everything collapsed. I was near the entrance and that was how I managed to get out," Salmanov said.

Then a group of about 50 Azeri men attempted to break through the police cordon after an officer refused to allow a man to go and identify a dead relative.



[align=left]



[align=right]Vladimir Filonov / MT[/align]
Nasired Magomedova, left, crying Thursday. Her husband was in the market.[/align]


As news came through of each increase in the death toll -- it grew by 10 in the space of two hours Thursday afternoon -- relatives of the victims screamed and burst into tears.

An ambulance medic -- one of 50 that the authorities sent to the scene -- was staying nearby with sedative pills, water and injections for injuries.

The injured were rushed to hospitals Nos. 29, 36, 52 and the Sklifosovsky First Aid Institute.

Yury Akimov, first deputy head of the Emergency Situations Ministry's Moscow branch, said people under the debris were calling from their mobile phones, helping to direct rescuers, Interfax reported. Also, sniffer dogs were pointing rescuers to where people might be, he said.

Six cranes were able to approach the debris and clear big concrete slabs only after rescue workers cut the over-the-road electric tram wires that blocked the way.

Around 5.45 p.m. rescue workers said that there was no hope left of finding anyone alive underneath the collapsed roof. The Emergency Situations Ministry said it stopped looking for survivors on Friday morning.

Azeri Health Minister Oktai Shiraliyev arrived in Moscow on Saturday to arrange for the transportation of Azeri victims' bodies to their native country for burial. He praised Moscow's disaster relief efforts, including the treatment of the injured.

"Everything is being done to the fullest extent and even in excess of it," he told Channel One television after visiting a hospital.

The government's top sanitary official, Gennady Onishchenko, said on Saturday that workers should not sleep at markets overnight, when the markets should be closed. The vendors would not have died if they had complied with this rule, he said, RIA-Novosti reported.

The State Duma faction of the nationalist Rodina party said it intended to ask City Hall for a list of buildings designed by Kancheli because "perhaps all of these buildings Е pose a threat to Muscovites," party leader Dmitry Rogozin said, Interfax reported.

City Hall closed the central Danilovsky market, which has a domed roof, immediately after the Basmanny market collapse on Thursday, and it remained closed Saturday when NTV television showed workers shoveling snow from its roof.

President Vladimir Putin ordered an investigation into the collapse Thursday. "We will have to conduct a thorough investigation and get objective information about the causes," he said.

On Friday, Luzhkov said he expected the cleanup to be completed by Monday, Interfax reported. A new shopping mall would be built on the site of the market, he said.

Luzhkov said Moscow had several other buildings whose roofs were designed by Kancheli.

 

+-RWD Stats

Members
Total Members: 8889
Latest: UA2006
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 546363
Total Topics: 20980
Most Online Today: 1511
Most Online Ever: 194418
(June 04, 2025, 03:26:40 PM)
Users Online
Members: 5
Guests: 1455
Total: 1460

+-Recent Posts

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by olgac
Yesterday at 06:04:33 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by olgac
Yesterday at 06:00:14 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by Trenchcoat
Yesterday at 04:54:09 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by Trenchcoat
Yesterday at 04:40:33 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by olgac
Yesterday at 02:56:15 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by 2tallbill
Yesterday at 02:49:45 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by olgac
Yesterday at 02:43:19 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by 2tallbill
Yesterday at 02:25:52 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by olgac
Yesterday at 12:09:23 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by Trenchcoat
Yesterday at 12:01:22 PM

Powered by EzPortal