It appears you have not registered with our community. To register please click here ...

!!

Welcome to Russian Women Discussion - the most informative site for all things related to serious long-term relationships and marriage to a partner from the Former Soviet Union countries!

Please register (it's free!) to gain full access to the many features and benefits of the site. Welcome!

+-

Author Topic: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people  (Read 3845 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline JayH

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5685
  • Country: au
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Ukraine
  • Status: Looking > 5 years
  • Trips: > 10
Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« on: December 19, 2013, 09:03:16 PM »
 http://www.dpcamps.org/jewsVsUkrainians.html

Efforts to reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian People


by Olga Kaczmar, 2005

The Ukrainians don't hate the Jews in particular; they hate everyone who has tried to control and rule over them. They hated the Mongols who destroyed the Kievan Rus empire, the Ottoman Turks, the Poles, the Austrians, the Germans, the Russians. They hated the Jews who sided with the Russians, the Jews who sided with the Poles and the Jews who sided with the Germans. They hated the Jews under the Austria, when Jews were put in between Austrian aristocracy and Rusyn peasants in Galicia.

Having the richest soil in Europe proved to be an impossible asset to protect, but Ukrainians fought to the death to hold onto it. It was a fight for survival of the fittest. When the US helped USSR and Poland during World War II, it did so at the expense of Ukrainian blood. Centuries of slaughter of Ukrainian people by all usurping nations, left a bottleneck gene pool, which was very hostile to outsiders, distrustful and very nationalistic. Ukraine's 19th century poet and foremost national hero, Taras Shevchenko wrote: "My beautiful country, so rich and resplendent! Who has not tormented you" (Journey Across Russia, The Soviet Union Today by Bart McDowell, pg. 165).

Many Jewish authors and writers are very anti-Ukrainian, with as much vehemence against Ukrainians as anti-Semitism. Yehuda Bauer, in his book, A History of the Holocaust, goes out of his way to portray Ukrainians as the 'bad guys'. I chastize him for taking isolated instances of violence and stigmatizing the whole Ukrainian population as anti-Semitic. One must look at the whole evolutionary history of these two groups, the development of hatred along with the rise of nationalism, who really controlled Ukraine during this violence, and who controlled the violence against the Jews.

One example of inaccuracy portrayed, Bauer wrote (page 65), "The nationalist Ukrainian government under Semyon Petlura (after November 1918) failed to prevent outrages against Jews." Once again, this is perpetuating a distortion of Ukrainian / Jewish relationships. The truth was that Petlura had actually issued orders to his army not to be involved in pogroms; and Petlura was assassinated in Paris in 1926 by Sholem Schwartzbart, a Jew who was a Soviet agent according to CIA director Allen Dulles (Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000).

Throughout his book, Bauer targets the Ukrainians as co-conspirators to the Nazis. In actual numbers, Ukrainians were far greater victims than were the Jews in World War II and before:

1. Stalin imposed a famine-genocide, which took 10 million lives in 1932-33. However, Bauer glossed over and wrote, "By the mid-thirties, about 160,000 Jews were settled on land [southern Ukraine], 40,000 to 60,00 of them by the JDS." Bauer doesn't tell you that this was to repopulate the lands were the Ukrainian villages were totally wiped out by the artificially-created famine, ethnic cleansing of the Ukrainian population. Occupying the farms of the starved Ukrainians, the Jews were instrumental in hiding the fact that there was a genocide. Stalin brought in families from all over Russia to repopulate the missing, later arranging guided tours of international news reporters to show them that there was NO starvation here! Further, Stalin's infamous henchman Lazar Kaganovich, of Jewish origin, was responsible for collectivization, and engineered the terrible 1933 famine (Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000).
2. During World War II, Ukrainian population lost another 10 million people. Hitler occupied Ukraine totally, and the well-manicured fields and villages of Ukraine were repeatedly a battleground. Both Stalin and Hitler wanted to erase Ukrainians, both burned out Ukraine upon retreat, leaving uncounted numbers to die from starvation and exposure in the winter. Subsequently, Stalin publicly listed those casualties as Russian casualties, not Ukrainian. In later years, Khrushchev included 16 million civilians. The majority of these victims were non-Russian, mostly Ukrainians (http://infoukes.com/history/ww2/page-01.html, 2004).

Ukraine lost more people in WW II than any other European country, estimated at 11 million people by Stephan G. Prociuk (Annals of the Ukrainian Academy of Arts and Sciences in the US):

"At the end of the war, Ukraine lay in ruins; the populations had declined by 25 per cent -- that is by approximately 10.5 million people; 6.8 million killed or died of hunger or disease, and the remainder had been evacuated or deported to Soviet Asia as political prisoners or had ended up as slave labor or émigrés in Hitler's Germany..." wrote Ann Lencyk Pawliczko in Ukraine and Ukrainians Throughout the World (University of Toronto Press, 1994, p.62).
Still others estimate Ukrainian losses at 13.9 million. "The Museum of World War II in the capital Kiev has a simple sign on marble which states: 'In 1940 in Ukraine lived 41.3 million people. In 1945 - 27.4 million people.' About 8 million Ukrainian citizens [not soldiers] (other estimates say 10 million) were killed in World War II" wrote Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000.
According to the University of Hawaii democide table, Slavs were killed at twice the rate of the Jews. Also, it shows the heaviest democide at over 12 million USSR population (Univ. of Hawaii). Remember, that Ukrainians were listed as citizens of USSR and Poland; and Hitler occupied Ukraine for 3 years before he entered Russia proper (http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/NAZIS.TAB1.1.GIF, 2004).

Norman Davies, professor and author of God's Playgound: A History of Poland, calculated that approximately five million Jews died in the war, compared with five million ethnic Poles and as many as 11 million Ukrainians.

3. At first, the Ukrainians were happy when Germany invaded because believing they were going to be liberated from the Satanic Stalin. The Nazi's were promising independence for Ukraine. They later found out that Hitler came to rob Ukraine of everything of value; food, their children, their young men / women to be used as a labor force, and in addition, trainloads of soil were routed to Germany.

4. The Ukrainian people didn't have independent action against the Jews; since either the Russians or the Germans orchestrated and dominated them. The Ukrainian police under Russia (called Ukrainische Hilfungspolizei / Ukrainian Auxiliary Police) was not Ukrainian by origin, but transplants from Russia and other nationalities. "The Ukrainian police under Nazis 'were also Volksdeutsch, Russians, Poles, Balts, Tartars, Armenians, Hungarians, and Romanians. Particularly notorious were the 'Ukrainian' police in the Warsaw ghetto who were not Ukrainians at all. They were Russians who were members of the Vlasov Russian Liberation Army (former Waffen SS No. 29) and not Ukrainians according to Professor Yaroslav Bilinsky" (Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000).

5. The Ukrainian Army controlled by the Germans was called Galizien Division. One provision the Galizien Division insisted on was that they fight only the Russians and not the western Allies (http://infoukes.com/galiciadivision/essay, 2004). The Waffen SS Galizien recruited three times as many Dutchmen as Ukrainians (http://infoukes.com/history/ww2/page-01.html, 2004).

As far as anti-Semitism charges brought against them, "In its final report, issued March 12, 1987, the Deschenes Commission completely cleared the Galicia Division of all charges of war criminal activity" (Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000).
6. For the three years Hitler occupied Germany, it ruled Ukraine, dividing it into five administrative districts. There was no Ukrainian government, therefore was not be a collaborator as was Vichy France, Hungary, Romania, or Slovakia (Andrew Gregorovich, 1998-2000).
7. The real Ukrainian army, a mere 200,000 Ukrainian partisans, was the UPA and they were not anti-Semitic. There were 8 Jewish doctors in the UPA, most valuable assets to the survival of an army.

"Many Jews could be found in the UPA, as doctors and medical orderlies. Stories of Jewish UPA doctors fighting it out with Nazis or Soviets to the end to protect their patients were not uncommon. At its peak in 1944, the UPA had around 500,000 men and women from various nationalities within its ranks, working as soldiers, medics, informants, saboteurs, etc." (http://members.aol.com/shukhevych/, 2004).
UPA actions intensified after WWII when former prisoners of war and slave workers, who were forcefully repatriated from Germany and deported to Siberia and other remote parts of USSR (Compiled by George Skoryk, from information contained in Encyclopedia Britannica, 2004).
8. Ukraine was the only country that fought a 3-front war during WW II: against Poland, against Germany and against Russia. Hitler retaliated by killing 20 (later boosted up to 100) innocent Ukrainian citizens for every soldier he lost and then he ordered them to be strung up from balconies to rot, a reminder to those who would want to help the partisans.

9. Ukraine was the only country that continued to fight WW II until 1956 (General Roman Shukhevych, Commander of UPA, kept the guerrilla war going against USSR, five years after World War II, until he was killed in action in 1950.) Something as unique as that, did not make it into the history of WW II? During WWII, Ukrainians had little to loose. They had lost their lands, their farm animals, tools and implements as well as families to the Stalin regime. Later the Germans came in and took their youth, the last of their food and burned out their shelter. So dying for Ukrainian freedom was the only honorable thing to do. Dying for Ukraine is an ongoing theme passed down through poetry. Young men took to the woods and kept killing Soviet soldiers. "Then many partisans, fully armed, crossed through Czechoslovakia to Austria and Germany and surrendered to Western occupational authorities" (Compiled by George Skoryk, from information contained in Encyclopedia Britannica, 2004).

"Fighting it out to the end, Shukhevych killed himself and several nearby Soviets with his last grenade...The UPA's last official military engagement occurred in October 1956, when some UPA survivors fought bravely on the Hungarian border to assist the Hungarian anti-Communist revolt" (http://members.aol.com/shukhevych/, 2004).

10. According to Ukrainian estimates about 3,000,000 Ukrainians were sent to Germany and Austria to work in factories as zwangsarbeiter (forced labor) and the Ostarbeiter (east workers, i.e. Ukrainian slaves). Thousands died on the factory floor of exhaustion and starvation. Others died in the Allied bombings. My mother, from Galicia, went willingly for job opportunities but then was converted to slave labor. My Ukrainian friend's mother stayed alive on one slice of bread and one cup of watery soup every day.

11. Evidence to annihilate: "No documentary evidence exists of Hitler's order to eliminate all Jews in Europe but we know this is true. Likewise, we have no Hitler order to annihilate the Ukrainians. But we do have the evidence (http://infoukes.com/history/ww2/):

• Millions of civilian victims perished which could not be "accidental."
• Documentary evidence of the wholesale executions of Ukrainians.
• The order to execute up to 100 innocent Ukrainians for one German soldier shot by the partisans and 460,000 German soldiers were killed by partisans and guerillas.
• German documents attest that the The Ostarbeiter Ukrainian slaves were to be 'worked to death' in Germany. Armaments minister Alber Speer wrote that his work force was dwindling, that he needed a fresh supply of 40,000 every month, a rate of 10,000 a day. (http://infoukes.com/history/ww2/page-13.html)
• Millions of prisoners of war were intentionally starved to death in concentration camps.
• Ukrainian cities were starved to death according to plan.
• Nazi leaders said that Ukraine, as the Lebensraum (new living space) of Nazi Germany, would be colonized by German population and some Ukrainians would be used as slave labor.
• Ukrainians disproportionate civilian losses compared to military also indicate a special Nazi German campaign.
• Reichmarshal Goeing, second to Hitler in power, said: "This year between twenty and thirty million persons will die [in Ukraine and] Russia of hunger. Perhaps it is well that it should be so, for certain nations must be decimated." Nov. 24-27, 1941 (Dallin p.123)
• Like Bormann and Goering, SS leader Heinrich Himler said that "the entire Ukrainian intelligentsia must be decimated." (Dallin, p. 127)
12. Many Ukrainians were involved in the rescue of Jews during the Nazi occupation. On 8 November 1992, The Ukrainian Weekly reported that during the first Jewish Congress of Ukraine, held in Kiev, "48 awards were handed out to Ukrainians and people of other nationalities who had rescued Jews during the Second World War."
While the Roman Catholic Church kept silent about deportation of Jews, "Metropolitan Andrey Sheptytsky distributed a pastoral letter against the persecution of Jews in Ukraine titled 'Thou Shalt Not Kill', and the clergy and faithful of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, particularly Metropolitan Sheptytsky, hid hundreds of Jews in monasteries and convents" (http://www.infoukes.com/religion/sheptytsky/, 2004).

"During the Nazi occupation of Ukraine, Metropolitan Sheptytsky enlisted the services of 500 monks and nuns to help save Jews from death," said Mr. Vesselovsky (http://www.ukrweekly.com/Archive/1996/439621.shtml, 2004).

13. After WWII, the Polish were awarded their partition of Ukraine, another Ukrainian massacre followed, called Operation Vistula. All battlefronts were quiet when another confidential bloodbath began. In 1946-47, Poland began a campaign to rid itself of the disgusting Ukrainian peasants (my forefather's homestead from the 1700s) off 'their new lands'. The Polish government is still claiming that it was a voluntary deportation. Figures & statistics vary depending on whose presentation. It is estimated that 65,000 to 70,000 people were deported according to Poland: A Country Study which justifies it in this manner:

"In the late 1940s, the main roles of the military were resettlement of Poland's newly acquired western territory, helping in economic reconstruction, and waging a three-year civil war against Home Army supporters, Ukrainian nationalist and various outlaw bands* in the foothills of the Carpathian Mountains. Some 70,000 people were arrested by internal security and military authorities in the repression of civil uprising between 1945 and 1948" (page 238).
*The emphasis is mine. With a straight face, they can tag 70,000 people as outlaw bands -- that was a substantial portion of the population of the mountainside.

14. As early as 1944, a Soviet decree signed by Zhukov and Beria (later murdered also) recommend that all Ukrainian be resettled in Siberia. "From 1944 to the late 1950's, the Berianist Soviet government repressed the Ukrainians. A total of three million Ukrainians (out of a 1950 population of 53 million) were eventually deported to Siberian labour camps, while another million Ukrainians died as a direct result of political terror" (http://www.ahtg.net/TpA/ukr2001.html, 2004).
Others claim 178,000 were dispersed and 60,000 remain in Poland. Unfortunates, without a roof over their heads, elderly or ill, and nothing to eat, decided to die on their native soil, rather than go to the Soviet Union. In order to save bullets, the Polish soldiers bayoneted & bludgeoned old women who refused to leave on a wide-scale basis. (This is documented by Committee Against Mass Expulsion, Ukrainian Congress Committee of America, NY 1948, 7-32 reprinted in volume 2/1975 of Annals of the World Lemko Federation.) Isn't it nice to know that commemorative crosses mark the spots where Polish soldiers perished in the voluntary transfer of these bandits but nothing for the Galician peasants who were massacred?

15. Ukrainian Congress Committee of America statistics (of Operation Vistula) say 750,000 were killed outright or relocated to Siberia in cattle cars without food, suitable clothing or sanitary provisions for the winter trip. Many thousands died along the way and their bodies were thrown out of the trains to be buried in the dead snows until the spring thaw.

16. "There are no official figures but experts in Gulag matters estimate the number of those who perished at Sanok (my mother's city in Poland) at 20 to 25 thousand. No water, food once a day, at night. The camp kapos were German prisoners. They carried huge rods and beat everyone. Here too, orders came unexpectedly. At the double, fall in, two thousand in each column, that's how many each train took. You had to climb in after running between specially trained guards. Armed young soldiers, one to four or five prisoners. A hundred into each truck, packed in like sardines, and off they went on a journey lasting weeks, into the interior of the Ukraine, and from there on towards the Caucasus and Siberia" (by Miklós Zelei, Hungarian Quarterly, VOLUME XXXVIII, No. 146, Summer 1997 - Some Highlights).

Up to 30 million people are estimated by Western historians to have died between 1918 and 1956 in Stalinist repression, civil war, famine and collectivization, although the true figure may never be known.

Continue to page 2   http://www.dpcamps.org/jewsVsUkrainians.html
Search this site powered by FreeFind
 
If this site was helpful to you, please consider making a donation to keep it going.
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
or

If you have anything relevant to add to this sections,
e-mail: Olga Kaczmar / USA
« Last Edit: December 19, 2013, 09:05:06 PM by JayH »
SLAVA UKRAYINI  ! HEROYAM SLAVA!!!!
Слава Украине! Слава героям слава!Слава Україні! Слава героям!
 translated as: Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!!!  is a Ukrainian greeting slogan being used now all over Ukraine to signify support for a free independent Ukraine

Offline JayH

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5685
  • Country: au
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Ukraine
  • Status: Looking > 5 years
  • Trips: > 10
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #1 on: December 19, 2013, 11:07:42 PM »
Efforts to reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian People,
page 2


by Olga Kaczmar, 2005

 

17. The Jews restricted to living in the Pale of Settlement, primarily in Ukraine and Belarus, did not claim Ukrainian identity but Russian, even though they were not allowed to live in Russia proper, their allegiance to the Russian authority was obvious. This used to baffle me that Jews in Kiev would identify themselves as Russian Jews; whereas Ukrainians refused to be labeled Russian, unless, of course, they were transplants from Russian boundaries which was Stalin's plan to homogonize Ukraine. (This later is illustrated clearly by the Orange Revolution in 2005, where the Eastern half of Ukraine wanted the Russian-backed Victor Yanukovych, while the Western half wanted Victor Yushenko, the Ukrainian candidate.)

18. Ukrainians were the only group that was committing suicide rather than be deported back to USSR as per the Yalta agreement population exchange.

19. The Ukrainian / Jewish conflict escalated when famed Nazi hunter, Wiesenthal, went after low-level Ukrainian guards such as John Demjaniuk; while upper level officers like Wiesenthal were excused from prosecution. Wiesenthal is accused first of collaborating with the Soviets and later with the Nazis to save his hide.

"Did Wiesenthal voluntarily work for his wartime oppressors? That's the accusation leveled by Austrian Chancellor Bruno Kreisky, himself of Jewish ancestry and leader for many years of his country's Socialist Party. During an interview with foreign journalists in 1975, Kreisky charged Wiesenthal with using 'Mafia methods', rejected his pretense of 'moral authority', and suggested that he was an agent for the German authorities" (http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v15/v15n4p-8_Weber.html, 2004).

Ukrainian author Myron B. Kuropas wrote about Wiesenthal:

"In 1939, he claims to have bribed an NKVD commissar and was spared deportation to Siberia along with other bourgeois Jews in Galicia. In 1941, he was saved from execution by a Ukrainian auxiliary policeman named Bodnar who spirited him away from the Nazis during the night. Later, Mr. Wiesenthal was singled out of a line of Jews – all of whom were summarily executed minutes later – by an SS officer who later provided him with double food rations. One can't help but wonder if these incidents were really the miracles Mr. Wiesenthal claims they were... Having studied Mr. Wiesenthal's recent releases and publications from Vienna and Los Angeles, I am increasingly convinced that he may be collaborating closely with the KGB and that in addition to wanting to live to see the last living Nazi on earth hanged, he appears to have an almost pathological need to discredit the Ukrainian and Baltic communities in the free world" (http://www.ukrweekly.com/Archive/1986/188613.shtml, 2004).

20. Richard C. Lukas wrote:

"The genocidal policies of the Nazis resulted in the deaths of as many Polish Gentiles as Polish Jews, thus making them co-victims in a Forgotten Holocaust. This Holocaust has been largely ignored because historians who have written on the subject of the Holocaust have chosen to interpret the tragedy in exclusivistic terms--namely, as the most tragic period in the history of the Jewish Diaspora. To them, the Holocaust was unique to the Jews, and they therefore have had little or nothing to say about the nine million Gentiles, including three million Poles, who also perished in the greatest tragedy the world has ever known. Little wonder that many people who experienced these events share the feeling of Nobel Laureate Czeslaw Milosz, who anxious when the meaning of the word Holocaust undergoes gradual modifications, so that the word begins to belong to the history of the Jews exclusively, as if among the victims there were not also millions of Poles, Russians, Ukrainians, and prisoners of other nationalities." -- Richard C. Lukas, preface to The Forgotten Holocaust: The Poles under German Occupation 1939-1944 (http://www.uca.edu/divisions/academic/history/cahr/holocaust.htm, 2004).

21. "Historical literature of the Holocaust has focused on the six million Jewish victims to the exclusion of the sixteen to twenty million Gentile victims," Karen Silverstrim, MA Candidate, University of Central Arkansas.

22. Before Jews became the primary target, Poles were shipped to Auschwitz by the tens of thousands.150,000 Polish Catholics went to Auschwitz. In Sachsenhausen, 20,000 Poles perished, in Mauthausen, 30,000, in Neuengamme, 17,000 (Lukas 38); 35,000 went to Dachau, 33,000 Polish women went to Ravensbrück many of them to be experimented upon, with glass and other objects implanted in their uteruses. In view of that, to hear from uninformed members of the Jewish community that Poles participated in the annihilation of Jews makes you ask, "has the world really gone mad?"... "Yet even in these circumstances, at least one million people were involved in sheltering Jews (Lukas 150). In these circumstances, every one of them was a saint, a hero, deserving no fewer accolades than Raul Wallenberg who was sheltered from Nazi retribution by his nationality, wealth and social status. In contrast, Poles who helped Jews were protected by nothing," (http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~sarmatia/498/thompson.html, 2004).

23. "Poland's population losses during World War II were proportionately by far the greatest
[Davies biasely forgetting the Ukrainian 10 million loss] of any nation participating in the war. Of its 35 million people before the war, Poland lost 6.5 million. An estimated 664,000 were battlefield deaths (this figure exceeds combined losses of the United States and Great Britain in WW II), and the remainder, or 90 percent, were civilians of all ages" (Norman Davies, Europe: A History, Oxford 1996, 1328; Richard Lukas, The Forgotten Holocaust, Univ. of Kentucky Press 1986, 39; The 1992 Almanac, Houghton Mifflin 310) (http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~sarmatia/498/losses.html, 2004).

24. California State University Dominguez Hills professor and author, Aaron Hass, perpetuates the myth that the Jews were the only ones who suffered; suffered the most, and especially, weren't helped by any other nationality. I took his class and lecture after lecture, he kept stating that the Jewish Holocaust (6 million) was the biggest genocide in history, ignoring the 7-10 million Stalin genocide of Ukrainians, even after I brought it up. In Hass' book, The Aftermath, Living with the Holocaust, he wrote that "Even the Palestinian Jews resented European Jews coming into Palestine," jealously guarding the precious hard-fought land and resources with other Jews.

25. Holocaust writer, Alexander Kimel also adds fuel to the Ukrainian-Jewish fire, perpetuating the long-standing arguments that Ukrainians were not only bystanders but PARTNERS with the Nazis. His thesis is full of accusations and half-truths, blaming the Ukrainians rather than allow that they were victims themselves, succumbing to as many deaths as the Jews. Kimel would be more accurate if he said SOME Ukrainians in every sentence that he writes because Ukrainians weren't acting in a cohesive group but were taking orders either from Soviets or Nazis. Historians forget quickly that World War II, fought on Ukrainian soil with large-scale battles in Kyiv, Lviv, Kharkiv, Odessa, and Sevastopol (http://members.aol.com/shukhevych/) and that it was a life and death struggle for the Ukrainian people. Kimel says Ukrainians played an extensive role in the Final Solution, which is a gross exaggeration of their powers under Hitler's command. He uses 17th Century Bogdan Chmielnicki (correct spelling Khmel'nyts'ki) example as proof of the Ukrainian serf bloody uprising against the Poles and killing the Jews when in fact, his bloody period was NOT about the Jews. The Cossack warrior Khmel'nyts'ki 's entire family was killed by the Poles, his estate was confiscated, he was bloody angry and he had nothing else to lose. The war he unleashed was about survival and struggle for land and they were ALL killing each other, with the Cossack being the victors. And yes, the Jews sided with the Poles and were the enemy to the Galician peasants. Kimel knows very little about Ukrainian history and inaccurately writes:

"Ukrainians were never a free people, always under the Polish or Russian yoke" when in truth Ukraine's history is older than the Russian history, i.e., -- beginning in 850s, the Kievan Rus reached the height of his power in the 10th century.

You can't trust Kimel's interpretation of history since it is one-sided and bares only a slight resemblance to the truth. I'm not defending atrocities; the atrocities were dealt by both two-sides of the Khmel'nyts'ki's peasant revolt (http://www.kimel.net/Ukraine.html 2004).

26. As all Ukrainians weren't on the same side, not all Jews were either. According to Bryan Mark Rigg (B.A. Yale, M.A. and Ph.D. Cambridge) there were at least 150,000 Jews devotedly helping 'der Fuehrer' to conquer the world. Among these Nazi lackeys were decorated veterans and high-ranking officers, even generals and admirals (see the 526-page historical treatise HITLER'S JEWISH SOLDIERS by Bryan Mark Rigg, the University Press of Kansas, May 2002, ISBN 0-7006-1178-9).

27. Ukraine, whenever it was free to rule itself, had no anti-Jewish legislation.

"Ukrainian paper currency from this period [1917] is probably the only money in the world which was printed in four languages--Ukrainian, Polish, Russian and Yiddish" (The Ukrainians in America, Myron B. Kuropas,1972, pg. 29).

28. Author Yakov Suslensky, imprisoned for seven years for speaking of anti-Soviet propaganda, spoke of the Volksdeutch:

Among the collaborators and residents at the time were those called Ukrainians, but who were of German descent, with strong German allegiance, born in Ukraine but were not of Ukrainian Rus history and nationality. "These were the ones who joined the Einisatszkommando or the Gestapo" (http://isurvived.org/Frameset4References/-Mirchuk-onJudenrat.html). Yakov Suslensky's 1995 book is They Were True Heroes: Citizens of Ukraine-Righteous Among the Nations.

29. The Jewish commemorate the 65th anniversary of the tragedy of Babyn Yar, however, for the sake of objectivity, it should be recalled that at least half the victims at Babyn Yar (if not more) were gypsies and Ukrainians, who were viciously destroyed by the Nazis. According to official German records 33,771 Jews were killed in two days; but the killing did not stop there. Babiy Yar became the burial place not only of Jews but of Ukrainians, Russians, Hungarians, Czechs, gypsies and prisoners of war. No one will ever know how many people died at Babiy Yar, but estimates put the figures at more than 100,000, 33,771 Jews.

Among the victims were also entire crews of ships of the famous Dnipro Flotilla as well as the defenders of Kyiv-soldiers and commanders of the Southwestern Front. Here is the grave of the unvanquished Olena Teliha and other Ukrainian patriots shot by the Gestapo in 1942, whose memory are for some reason not being honored on the state level. (PRESS CONFERENCE, UNIAN, Kyiv, Ukraine, Thu, Sep 28, 2006, Action Ukraine Report (AUR) #770, Article 5, Kyiv, Ukraine, Sunday, October 8, 2006)

30. About half of the 200,000 Ukrainians were resettled by the International Refugee Organization (IRO) to USA, UK, Australia and Canada. Marta Dyczok provides an explanation why the Grand Alliance [Roosevelt, Churchill, Stalin] did not recognize the Ukrainian nationality of the refugees. In the words of one Western official, Ukrainian patriots were to be considered as fascists and enemies of the people. The Grand Alliance and Ukrainian Refugees, (2000; ISBN 0-333-71109-2) Marta Dyczok, Assistant Professor, Departments of History and Political Science University of Western Ontario, Chapter 3 (p. 47).

31. Stefan Lemieszewski writes: Furthermore, part of Stalin's tactics used in forced repatriation included a propaganda campaign falsely smearing Ukrainian refugees as Nazi war criminals (today, a continuing campaign).

32. General Eisenhower, who initially supported the forcible repatriation (from Germany to Russia) policy, gradually became appalled by the "suicides among individuals who preferred to die than return to their native lands.'' On 4 September 1945 he overstepped his authority and suspended the use of force in repatriation in the US zones of operation in Germany. Two months later Field Marshal Montgomery introduced a similar suspension in the British zones. (http://www.dpcamps.org/repatriation.html)

33. In best-selling novel of 1983, Poland, author/researcher James A Michener wrote:

Ukraine would become one of the world's greatest tragedies, a land in which the oppressors would allow ten million citizens to starve to death [1932-33], where the native language would be outlawed, and where all kinds of depredations would be visited upon a distrusted and despised subject people. In despair, in 1939 the Ukrainians would try to side with Hitler in hopes that he might rescue them from Russian domination, and when this proved a fatal miscalculation, the revenge of the Communist victors would be harsher than ever.

34. The archives even contain documents proving that in the 1950s, in order to divert attention from Russia’s crimes in the Holodomor, Russia convinced the East German secret police, the Stasi, to forge documents alleging that Ukrainian nationalists had collaborated with the Nazis against Jews during World War II. [SSU (SBU) site English version: http://www.sbu.gov.ua/sbu/control/en/index and
http://www.sbu.gov.ua/sbu/control/uk/publish/article?art_id=74497&cat_id=80545&mustWords=„Štazi&searchPublishing=1]

In fact, the opposite is true – Ukrainians and their military, political and religious leaders proactively opposed German persecution of Jews and worked to protect and rescue Jews from Nazis.  Article by Peter Borisow, New York, New York; Canadian American Slavic Studies, Vol. 42, No. 3, (Fall 2008). Pg. 251-265; Charles Schlacks, Publisher, Idyllwild, CA;[See Herbert Romerstein, “Divide and Conquer: The KGB Disinformation Campaign against Ukrainians and Jews,” Ukrainian Quarterly, LX, no. 3 (Fall 2004).]

35. The Jews will not honor Archbishop Metropolitan Sheptyts'kyi - Reason why Archbishop Sheptitsky has not (yet) been honored with Righteous Gentile award:

Turned down after consideration by Yad Vashem’s Commission for the Designation of the Righteous Among the Nations (the commission convenes more than 20 times each year in closed sessions) more than a dozen times since 1964, Metropolitan Sheptitsky remains arguably Yad Vashem’s most difficult case. While no one denies that he was responsible for the rescue of many Jews, his critics point to many factors that have made him ineligible to be named a Righteous Gentile: as Ukraine’s highest-ranking cleric, he putatively faced no personal danger for opposing the Germans’ Final Solution; as the acknowledged leader of the wartime Ukrainian nationalist movement, he originally welcomed the Nazis, seeing them as a means to Ukrainian independence; as the head of the Uniate church, he gave his blessings to the formation of two Ukrainian SS divisions; as a man with longtime sympathetic relations to the Jewish community, he did not proactively seek out Jews to assist but did open his church’s doors to people who approached him.

For more of the story, see:

http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/international-news/righteous-gentile-or-nazi-supporter

Submitted by: Lavrentiy

 

 

In closing:

The Ukrainian point of view is: "My God, Ukrainian blood was shed all over Europe, in Ukraine, in Germany, in Poland and in Russia, in far greater numbers than any other nationality. The Jews are trying to rewrite history to show they were most impacted and that Ukrainians were co-conspirators to Hitler."

What happened to the six millions Jews in World War II was horrific! What happened to the five million Poles was horrific! What happened to the 10 million Ukrainians was horrific! World War II was a raging hell for more than just the Jews. So yes, Jewish blood was on Ukrainian hands and Ukrainian blood was on Jewish hands. We've got to start the healing exchange between the Jews and the Ukrainians, not teach new generations to continue the hate. It's such an injustice to those million of Ukrainians who perished brutally between 1930 and 1950s.

Yehuda Bauer, Alexander Kimel, CBS's Morley Safer and Aaron Hass are divisive spokesmen. New kind of leaders are emerging who bring understanding between Jews and Ukrainians. Radio talk show host and commentator, Dennis Prager, teaches cohesiveness to Jews and Christians; encouraging them to support each other in common goals. Marco Carynnyk, is writer and spokesman on Jewish-Ukrainian relations. Together and Apart in Brzezany, by Dr. Shimon Redlich writes of the conflict in inter-war Galicia was between Ukrainians, Jews and Poles, pointing out prejudices, hatreds and how Poles, Jews and Ukrainians have perceived each other.

In 2005 the new Ukrainian president, Viktor Yushchenko, vows to bridge the gap caused by trouble relations under Czarist and Soviet regimes. He said on his last trip to Auschwitz he had gathered up soil, which he presented to a meeting of Ukrainian Jews. "And I will guarantee that in Ukraine there will never be anti-Semitism, xenophobia or hatred between people," he said. "There will never again be a Jewish question in my country. The tragedy of the past will never be repeated on the soil of Ukraine." Yuschenko's father, Andriy, was one of 14,000 Soviet [Ukrainian] soldiers, tattooed and held as slave labor in Auschwitz. (From article by Ron Popeski, Reuters, Krakow, Poland, January 27, 2005.)

New York, Monday, November 21, 2005 - The American Jewish Committee (AJC) welcomes the U.S. Senate vote to lift the trade restrictions on Ukraine that were imposed on the Soviet Union in 1974 when Congress adopted the Jackson-Vanik Amendment to press for freedom of emigration. AJC now will urge the U.S. House of Representatives to vote in support of lifting the restrictions on Ukraine, so the measure can be delivered to the White House for signature by President Bush.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Divide and Conquer: The KGB  disinformation campaign against Ukrainians and  Jews
http://www.iwp.edu/news/newsID.139/news_detail.asp

Ukrainian Quarterly November 8, 2004
By Herbert Romerstein

Herbert Romerstein is an adjunct professor at the Institute of  World Politics. He was a professional staff member of the Permanent  Select Committee on Intelligence of the US House of Representatives  and served as chief of the Office to Counter Soviet Disinformation and  Active Measures at the United States Information  Agency.

PAPERS & STUDIES
Ukrainian Quarterly
Publication Date: Fall  2004


Introduction

The Soviet regime had a serious image problem in the 1970s and '80s.  While the communist propaganda apparatus was trying to present Soviet Russia  as a normal peaceful state, in the United States and other free countries,  people of Ukrainian, Jewish and Baltic origin were working together to  expose the repressive and imperialist nature of the communist dictatorship. They picketed Soviet embassies, provided the press with names of prisoners  in the Soviet Gulag and demanded freedom for the peoples of the Soviet  empire.

The Politburo of the Soviet Communist Party assigned the KGB to solve  this problem. The Soviet secret police and intelligence service had a long  history of using disinformation to discredit political opponents. After the  collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Leonid Shabarshin, who formerly headed  the First Chief Directorate (Foreign Intelligence) of the KGB, explained to  the Moscow newspaper Trud that one of the jobs of the KGB was disinformation  for "compromising anti-Soviets.'"

In Shebarshin's words, "during the Cold War the essence of our active  measures was to inflict political and moral damage on our basic opponent,  the United States ... [so] we compromised political figures, organs of the  press, and Americans whose activities were in some way unwelcome [to the  Soviets]." The KGB veteran revealed that every "active measure" against the enemies of the Soviet Union abroad was submitted by KGB to the Politburo  "and was implemented only with its permission. The results of the action  were also reported to the Politburo."

The KGB was given the important job of creating division in the  anti-Soviet camp. English language propaganda books and pamphlets were  prepared with KGB assistance for dissemination in the West. One such  pamphlet complained that Ukrainian nationalists arrange noisy demonstrations  in support of the Israeli aggressors (as has happened in West Germany),  while the Zionist chieftains declare their ‘firm intention to continue close cooperation' with the OUN [Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists] killers.  Therefore, both partners in this wicked marriage publicly admit the real  nature of the sinister alliance between Zionists and Ukrainian bourgeois  nationalists.

To the Soviets, those who opposed them would only do so on orders of the  CIA. The pamphlet went on "The malignant partnership of the Magen David  [Star of David] and the nationalist trident [the Ukrainian national emblem],  fostered by the CIA, has long become a reality."

The Soviets used foreign communists to spread the  disinformation.One of them, Michael Hanusiak, a member of the Communist  Party of the United States (CPUSA), visited Ukraine in the early 1970s,  where the KGB provided him with information on Ukrainians who were  supposedly Nazi war criminals.

Soviet attempts to discredit Jews

During World War II, as a young communist, Hanusiak looked to  Michael Tkach as his friend and mentor. Tkach was the head of the Ukrainian  section of the International Workers Order, a communist front, and was  editor of the communist newspaper Ukrainian Daily News, based in New York.  He was also an agent of the NKVD, subsequently known as KGB, spying against  the United States. Later Hanusiak replaced Tkach as the editor of The Ukrainian News. It was no longer a daily but continued to publish Soviet  propaganda in New York.

In 1993 Hanusiak celebrated his 80th birthday. Gus Hall,  head of the CPUSA, wrote him, "On this special occasion we want to  congratulate you on your many years of outstanding contributions in the  leadership of the Communist Party, USA, as well as other progressive  organizations." Hanusiak's Communist Party comrade and close friend Lewis  Moroze wrote to him, "My wife Dora and I have a dream that in the not too  distant future the Soviet peoples will restore socialism to the Soviet  Union, and the Morozes and the Hanusiaks will join hands in a walk side by  side down the Krishchatik in the city of Kyiv in the Ukraine." It was too late for them: Ukraine was free and the Soviet Russian empire could never be  reestablished.

Hanusiak used some of the KGB information in a 1973 book called  Lest We Forget. It was republished in Canada in 1976 with introductions that  revealed its real purpose. One introduction signed Joshua Gershman  complained, "It is no secret that leaders of the capitalist political  parties in Canada - including Jews - are often honored guests at  celebrations of the Ukrainian nationalists and other chauvinist ethnic  community organizations, particularly at the time of elections.They express solidarity with the misleading slogans calling for the 'liberation'  of the Ukraine and other Soviet Republics. . . . Thus we witnessed in  Canada, in 1971, during the official friendship visit of Soviet Premier Kosygin, the ugly collaboration of cold warriors among the Jewish, Ukrainian, Hungarian and other ethnic groups, demonstrating against the  Soviet Union."

In another introduction to the book, Peter Krawchuk complained  that the Ukrainian nationalists and Zionists "in their hatred of the Soviet  Union ... have become partners." In reality, many of the Jews who opposed  the communist empire were not Zionist. The communists used the term  "Zionist" as a synonym for Jews. During World War II the NKVD used the code  word "Rats" for both Jews and Zionists. When the NKVD assigned agent Robert  Soblen (Ruvelis Sobolevicius) to take over the spying on Trotskyites and Jews in New York, the secret communication referred to them under the  code-names "polecats" and "rats."

It is interesting to note that at the same time, the Nazis in occupied  Ukraine tried to divide Ukrainians and Jews by distributing a leaflet saying  that "Jews are like rats." It showed a picture of a rat superimposed on the  Star of David, the same Jewish symbol that the above-mentioned Soviet  propaganda pamphlet, complained was in partnership with the Ukrainian  trident.

KGB methodology to divide Jews from Ukrainians and  Lithuanians

The KGB methodology in attempting to divide Jews from Ukrainians and  other ethnic groups can best be understood by examining a collection of  secret KGB materials discovered in Lithuania by the French scholar Francoise  Thom. The KGB used both agents and "co-optees." The KGB's official  definition of agent was "An individual who consciously, systematically and clandestinely carries out particular intelligence assignments in his own  country or abroad." The difference was that the agent was a full time  operative of any nationality, while the co-optee was a Soviet citizen, only  occasionally called upon to carry out KGB orders.

In July 1980 the KGB in Lithuania wrote a memorandum on "Suggestions on  active measures in connection with the attempts of the Zionists and  Lithuanian nationalist émigrés to coordinate their activities." According to  the memo, the "Zionists" had launched an anti-Soviet campaign which had been  reported in the Lithuanian language press in the West. The leaders of the Lithuanian nationalist groups made contact with Jewish groups "with the aim  of coordinating hostile activities against the Soviet Union with  them."

The campaign against the Lithuanians was assigned to two KGB agents code  named "Aleksas" and "Germanas" and two cooptees, Yu. Ronderis and Ya.  Vinitskas. (While the agents mentioned in KGB reports were given code names,  the co-optees were listed by their real names.) The KGB cooptee Yu. Ronderis  was assigned to find people in Israel who could sign statements addressed to  American Jews attacking the Lithuanians.

By 1987 the KGB's problems had intensified. Lithuanian nationalists were  publicly active in Lithuania. Morever, Lithuanian Jews were active in the  nationalist movement. One in particular, Emmanuel Zingeris, was a member of  the national board of the Lithuanian national rebirth movement, "Sajudis."  He is not a Zionist and describes himself as "a Lithuanian of Jewish background." Zingeris is now chairman of the Lithuanian Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights. Zingeris became a particular target of KGB  disinformation.

A top secret cable dated September 23, 1987 from the KGB in Moscow to the  KGB in Vilnius revealed that an agent with the code name "Yablonsky" had  been assigned to travel to Israel to try to discredit Zingeris. According to  the cable, "Before his departure for Israel 'Yablonsky' received an  assignment from Service Z of the Lithuanian KGB to discredit Zingeris with  Zionist circles." Service Z was the local section of Directorate Z (formerly 5th Directorate) of the KGB which had the job of persecuting  dissidents.

'Yablonsky' had relatives at Kol Israel broadcasting service. He was  ordered to tell them, as well as officials of the charitable organization,  The Jewish Agency, that Zingeris was involved with Lithuanian nationalists  who had murdered Jews. That was a lie, and 'Yablonsky' failed in his  mission. He explained to his KGB masters that The Jewish Agency, which  provided financial support to help Jews abroad, was receiving money from the  Joint Distribution Committee in the United States which would be angry with  anyone who attacked Zingeris. "Yablonsky" may not have given the KGB a true  excuse, but Zingeris was justifiably held in high regard by American  Jews.

The role of East Germany's Stasi

The East German Ministry for State Security, known as Stasi, worked  closely with the KGB. Like the KGB it was responsible for both internal  repression and espionage abroad. Naturally Stasi played an important role in  the disinformation campaign. With German efficiency, Stasi explained in a 1969 report how it conducted disinformation:

Periodicals will address specific persons and groups. One can select  actual events, problems etc. using a mixture of truths, half truths, fiction  and other well conceived interpretations, so the recipient finds them  believable, thus causing the anticipated success. Exact knowledge of  conditions within the particular government in the operational area is  imperative. Absolutely necessary is thorough knowledge of western language  use, as well as psychological, sensitive tactics in approach.

Stasi also explained how it responded to those who exposed human rights  violations in the communist empire. It considered the truth about communism  "harassment" and said in its report, "Through distribution of aggressively  directed messages, the enemy will be disinformed and forced to abandon his  harassment campaign thus keeping him disturbed and pointlessly occupied."  These activities were coordinated with the appropriate officials of the  Communist Party (SED). Stasi reported, "There are near daily conversations  with the member of the Politburo responsible for agitation in the West,  Comrade [Albert] Norden or Comrade [Werner] Lamberz, Secretary of the  Central Committee and Chairman of the Agitation Commission of the  Politburo." Albert Norden had been a German Communist Party activist since  he was 16 years old, in 1920. During World War II he operated in the United  States as a communist propagandist. In East Germany he served as the loudest  and most vicious voice against the West in the communist  dictatorship.

In 1959 he led the smear campaign against the West German Federal  Minister of Refugees, Theodor Oberlander. Norden issued a book attacking  Oberlander and at a press conference in East Berlin on October 22, 1959,  Norden identified Oberlander as the political commander of the Ukrainian  Nachtigall Unit, which together with the German Wehrmacht fought against the Soviet Union. That was the true part of Norden's story.

The false part was the claim that the military unit was involved in a  pogrom against the Jews of Lviv. The official reports of the Nazi  Einsatzgruppen of actions against the Jews, instigated by the Nazi  propaganda that the Jews were responsible for the communist atrocities  against Ukrainians, do not show that Nachtigall was involved. In a report  date July 16, 1941, we read, "In the first hours after the Bolshevik  withdrawal, the Ukrainian populations displayed commendable activity against  the Jews. For example, the Dobromil synagogue was set on fire and 50 Jews  were killed by the enraged crowd at Sambor. Maltreating them, the Lvov  inhabitants rounded up about 1000 Jews and took them to the GPU [i.e., NKVD]  prison which has been occupied by the Wehrmacht."

Active measures against Ukrainian leader Stephan  Bandera

Norden's book was the usual vile disinformation, but its worst charge  related to the murder of the leader of the Organization of Ukrainian  Nationalists, Stephan Bandera. According to Norden, Bandera "the Commander  of Nachtigall" was murdered on October 15, 1959 to prevent him from  revealing what he knew about the supposed crimes of Oberlander.

The commander of Nachtigall was not Bandera, but Roman  Shukhevych, who later commanded the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA). Bandera  was head of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN), the political movement, which on June 30, 1941, proclaimed reestablishment of an  independent Ukrainian state headed by Yaroslav Stetsko. The KGB then destroyed Bandera with the most intense method on the active measures spectrum: assassination. Bogdan Stashynsky, the KGB assassin, later defected  to West Germany and revealed how Soviet intelligence had ordered him to  murder the Ukrainian leader. He served a prison sentence in West Germany for his crime.

Bandera was hated both by the communists and the Nazis. On July 2,  1941, SS Einsatzgruppe B reported to the Chief of the Security Police that  "measures against the Bandera group, in particular against Bandera himself, are in preparation.They will be carried out as soon as possible." On July 9  the Ukrainian nationalist leaders, including Bandera (arrested already on  July 5) and Stetsko, were arrested by the SS. They spent most of the war as prisoners in Sachsenhausen concentration camp.

A Gestapo report dated August 18, 1941, reveals that "The OUN in Lvov  sells war-loan stamps and releases pamphlets demanding Bandera's return.  From Lvov, posters are released declaring that a ‘free and independent Ukraine' must be created according to the motto "Ukraine for the Ukrainians,  under the leadership of the OUN.' Orders of the German Army are frequently  ignored. ..."

While persecuting the OUN, the Nazis agitated the population against the Jews. The communists had helped them by murdering Ukrainian intellectuals,  officially considered enemies of Soviet power, before fleeing the German invasion. An Einsatzgruppe reported on July 16th that about twenty thousand  Ukrainians had disappeared from Lviv, eighty percent of them belonging to  the intelligentsia. The prisons were crammed with the bodies of murdered Ukrainians. In Dobromil eighty-two bodies were found. Four were of Jews.

One Ukrainian witness to the pre-war Soviet mass murders was the  journalist Apollon Trembowetskyi, also called Petro Pavlovych, who testified  before the United States House Committee on Un-American Activities that he wondered at the time "why so many were arrested, especially Ukrainians,  those of Polish decent - half Polish, half Ukrainian and many Jewish people  who were arrested in our town. ..."

Another eyewitness, whose identity was protected, gave his evidence to  the Ukrainian Historical Association. He had been a correspondent of  Trembowetskyi's newspaper Vinnytski Visty, and had access to the lists of victims found by the Nazis in Vinnytsia. The Nazis ordered him to publish  the nationality of Polish and Ukrainian victims but to list Russians, Jews  and Gypsies as "nationality unknown." The Nazis were agitating the  population against the Jews at the time and did not want it revealed that  the communists murdered Jewish intellectuals as well as Ukrainians.

Nazi and Communist triangulation against Ukrainians and Jews

The East German propagandists conveniently ignored the action of the Soviets, murdering millions of people of all nationalities - but  particularly intellectuals. The Stasi boasted that its campaign against  Oberlander had been successful and that he had been removed from the West  German government.

In 1974 Oberlander visited Washington, DC and participated in the  Congress of the World Anti-Communist League. British anti-communists had  warned that a neo-Nazi group from Latin America had infiltrated the Congress. Oberlander joined with Yaroslav and Slava Stetsko and the leaders  of the American delegation, former Congressman Walter Judd and Lee Edwards,  to expose and discredit the neo-Nazis.

The anti-Nazi caucus was successful and the neo-Nazis exposed themselves  when they voted against a resolution presented by Oberlander to condemn the  human rights violations in communist East Germany. The neo-Nazis supported  the communist dictatorship. At this writing, Mrs. Stetsko is a member of  Parliament in Free Ukraine.

Human rights leader Avraham Shifrin headed the Israeli delegation to the  WACL Congress. He had spent 10 years as a prisoner in a Soviet slave labor  camp. He told this writer that he had become a Zionist in the Gulag and how Ukrainians and Jews learned to work together when they were both being  persecuted by the same KGB. The Ukrainian Insurgent Army, led by Shukhevych, fought against the Nazis and continued the war against the communists until  the 1950s.

The horrors inflicted by both the Nazis and communists brought Ukrainians and Jews together. Jews participated in the UPA as well as other  anti-communist and anti-Nazi units. The Soviet propagandists  complained,

During the Great Patriotic War 1941-1945, many Zionists were  members of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) and the Ukrainian People's  Revolutionary Army (UPRA). For example, the Zionist Haim Sigal, alias  Sigalenko, was a chieftain and 'Bulba's' right-hand man. . . . A number of  Zionists such as Margosh, Maximovich, 'Kun' and others were officers in the  Ukrainian Insurgent Army. According to a report by a Nazi Einsatz-commando  Zionists closely cooperated with the Bandera ringleaders. The latter provided them with the forged German documents.

Only Nazis and communists could complain that Ukrainian nationalists saved the lives of Jews by providing them with false documents  during the Nazi occupation. That story happens to be true. A report to the  Chief of the Security Police in Berlin dated March 30, 1942 reveled that  "Today, it has been clearly established that the Bandera movement provided  forged passports not only for its own members, but also for Jews."

One Ukrainian who saved hundreds of Jews was the 86 year-old  leader of Ukraine's Catholics, Metropolitan Andrey Sheptytskyi. His story was told by Rabbi David Kahane, one of the Jews he rescued. With the help of  his brother, Abbot Kliment Sheptytskyi, the Metropolitan hid Jews and, according to Rabbi Kahane, continued to warn the Ukrainian people against evil and in his pastoral  letters he endeavored to keep them away from hatred in general and from  racial hatred in particular. He told us he was issuing a pastoral letter to the Ukrainian people and the clergy on the subject of mercy, in which he  stated emphatically that in these times of trial one must pity not only the Ukrainians and the Christians, but everyone, regardless of his  religion.

Rabbi Kahane later went to Israel where he became the Chief Rabbi of the Israeli Air Force.

Manufacturing 'Nazi war criminals'

The communists reviled Metropolitan Sheptytskyi and stated that he "never ever raised his voice against the mass annihilation of Lviv residents. . . .  " Rabbi Kahane exposed this lie. Communist hatred of the Jews was obvious when Soviet propagandists wrote, "We know from history that freedom of  thought and a scientific view of the world have always been mercilessly  suppress by Judaism."

But it was important to them to divide the Jews and Ukrainians in  the West who had joined together to expose the Soviet Russian totalitarian  regime. Thus, the KGB in Ukraine provided American communist Michael  Hanusiak with a list of alleged "Nazi war criminals" from Ukraine. While  caring little if at all for Nazi crimes against Jews, the communists  understood that Americans would want anyone who engaged in such activity,  regardless of their nationality, punished - no matter how long it  took.

The KGB wanted to use this legitimate concern of Americans as a weapon to  divide their Ukrainian and Jewish enemies, to discredit the large immigrant communities in the United States and Canada, and to discredit any emergence of Ukrainian nationalism.

One of the names Hanusiak brought to the United States was that of John Demianiuk (Demjanjuk). His name was given to the United States  Justice Department, which began an investigation of the retired Ohio auto  worker. Soon, Demianiuk was accused of being "Ivan the Terrible," a brutal  guard at the Nazi Treblinka death camp.

In the horrors that took place in that camp, "Ivan the Terrible" became a  legend as the cruelest of all the murderers. After undergoing a long legal  ordeal, Demianiuk was extradited to Israel where he was convicted and  sentenced to death. The collapse of the Soviet Union allowed access  to KGB files in Ukraine and probably saved the man's life. The evidence showed that "Ivan the Terrible" was Ivan Marchenko, not Demianiuk.  The Israeli court, after examining the new evidence, reversed the conviction  of Demianiuk and allowed him to return to the United States.

The question is - Who was Marchenko? He was a Soviet prisoner of war who  had volunteered to work for the Nazis as a camp guard. A 1961 KGB report on  the interrogation of Sergey Vasylyenko revealed that Marchenko was the man the Jews in the camp called "Ivan the Terrible."

According to Vasylyenko, "He exhibited special savagery in dealing with  people in the killing process, he killed people with an obvious satisfaction  and beat them with whatever was at hand and however he fancied."  More importantly, the KGB knew that toward the end of the war that  Marchenko had gone to Yugoslavia and joined with Tito's communist partisans. He remained in Yugoslavia after the war and the KGB knew of his whereabouts  in 1948-1949.

In the summer of 1948, Stalin broke with Tito. Soviet propaganda  accused Tito, who remained a committed communist, of being a fascist. In October 1949, the New York County Communist Party  issued a Discussion Outline and Study Guide entitled The Struggle Against  the Tito Fascists - Agents of Imperialism.

This theme permeated worldwide Soviet propaganda. However, KGB  propaganda never pointed out that the Tito government was harboring Ivan Marchenko, the Nazi war criminal known as "Ivan the Terrible." This issue raises the question as to whether Marchenko was not in fact a Soviet agent  carrying out his atrocities on the order of the NKVD (KGB). We know of other  cases where KGB operatives pretended to be anti-communists and carried out atrocities to blame them on their enemies and seize the moral high  ground.

The main piece of Soviet-provided evidence against Demianiuk was a  supposed identity card showing his name and picture at the Travniki training  camp for guards. The authenticity of the document was challenged as it was apparent that the picture had come from another document and that the card  contained other inaccuracies. That was not enough to acquit Demianiuk, but  the KGB's internal files released after the Soviet collapse convinced the Israelis of Demianiuk's innocence.

Internal KGB reports describe Soviet operations against Ukraine

In 1980 a report was prepared by KGB Colonel V. Medvedev titled "More Culture in the Work on the Nazi Criminals." It was published in the  internal, secret KGB magazine Sbornik KGB.

Colonel Medvedev boasted of the materials provided by KGB to the Western  governments to prosecute Nazi war criminals. However, he complained that  "the quality of the materials ... sometimes make it impossible to send the materials abroad." Such documents, he said, are usually sent back by KGB  headquarters to be redone: "The analysis of the weak points shows that  sometimes they are the result of the inattentiveness and inaccuracy of the functionaries."

KGB technicians often took a long time to fix them. As a result there was  a delay in providing the documents to the Western governments. In Medvedev's  words, "Practice shows that concrete evidence of the witnesses thoroughly  interrogated on a high professional level appear to be very important proof  in the Nazi criminal's cases." Some of the old interrogation transcripts  were so "standardized" that the constant repetition of phrases by different  witnesses made it apparent that they were false.

We had not seen these admissions during the 1980s when this writer was a  staff member of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, but  anti-communists such as Congressman John Ashbrook (R-Ohio), understood not  to trust the KGB. In retrospect it might seem strange to point out that U.S.  government officials, including lawyers, senior political appointees and  elected officials, did indeed trust the KGB-furnished information and were  critical of the skeptics. But the lawmaker saw fit to warn his colleagues  and the public.

In the Congressional Record of May 28, 1981 Congressman Ashbrook said,  "World War II ended 36 years ago but many of us still remember its horrors.  We should never forgive and never forget the atrocities committed by the Nazis against the Jews. The Nazi murders of 6 million Jews and millions of  Christians are crimes that require punishment of all who are guilty.  At the same time, we must not forget the Communist murders of even  greater millions of Christians, Jews, and Moslems. And we cannot forgive  these crimes. Hitler and Stalin and most of their top henchmen are dead.  But, the present leadership in the Soviet Union were all part of the Stalin  murder machine."

Ashbrook continued, "We cannot condemn anyone based on Soviet evidence,  but we must make sure that no Nazi or Communist criminal should receive  sanctuary here. We can be sure of this be using our basic American laws of evidence. Soviet evidence is tainted and should not be utilized in American courts."

Now we have available the evidence from the Soviet and other  communist archives of what really happened in the past. In the  future, we must honor those who fought and died against communist  dictatorship and learned in that struggle how people of different religions  and nationalities could work together against the common enemy.



Stalin's Jews
We mustn't forget that some of greatest murderers of modern times were Jewish
http://www.ynet.co.il/english/articles/0,7340,L-3342999,00.html
Published:  12.21.06, 23:35 / Israel Opinion

Here's a particularly forlorn historical date: Almost 90 years ago, between the 19th and 20th of December 1917, in the midst of the Bolshevik revolution and civil war, Lenin signed a decree calling for the establishment of The All-Russian Extraordinary Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage, also known as Cheka.

Within a short period of time, Cheka became the largest and cruelest state security organization. Its organizational structure was changed every few years, as were its names: From Cheka to GPU, later to NKVD, and later to KGB.

We cannot know with certainty the number of deaths Cheka was responsible for in its various manifestations, but the number is surely at least 20 million, including victims of the forced collectivization, the hunger, large purges, expulsions, banishments, executions, and mass death at Gulags.

Whole population strata were eliminated: Independent farmers, ethnic minorities, members of the bourgeoisie, senior officers, intellectuals, artists, labor movement activists, "opposition members" who were defined completely randomly, and countless members of the Communist party itself.

In his new, highly praised book "The War of the World," Historian Niall Ferguson writes that no revolution in the history of mankind devoured its children with the same unrestrained appetite as did the Soviet revolution. In his book on the Stalinist purges, Tel Aviv University's Dr. Igal Halfin writes that Stalinist violence was unique in that it was directed internally.

Lenin, Stalin, and their successors could not have carried out their deeds without wide-scale cooperation of disciplined "terror officials," cruel interrogators, snitches, executioners, guards, judges, perverts, and many bleeding hearts who were members of the progressive Western Left and were deceived by the Soviet regime of horror and even provided it with a kosher certificate.

All these things are well-known to some extent or another, even though the former Soviet Union's archives have not yet been fully opened to the public. But who knows about this? Within Russia itself, very few people have been brought to justice for their crimes in the NKVD's and KGB's service. The Russian public discourse today completely ignores the question of "How could it have happened to us?" As opposed to Eastern European nations, the Russians did not settle the score with their Stalinist past.

And us, the Jews? An Israeli student finishes high school without ever hearing the name ' Genrikh Yagoda,' the greatest Jewish murderer of the 20th Century, the GPU's deputy commander and the founder and commander of the NKVD. Yagoda diligently implemented Stalin's collectivization orders and is responsible for the deaths of at least 10 million people. His Jewish deputies established and managed the Gulag system. After Stalin no longer viewed him favorably, Yagoda was demoted and executed, and was replaced as chief hangman in 1936 by Yezhov, the "bloodthirsty dwarf."

Yezhov was not Jewish but was blessed with an active Jewish wife. In his book 'Stalin: Court of the Red Star', Jewish historian Sebag Montefiore writes that during the darkest period of terror, when the Communist killing machine worked in full force, Stalin was surrounded by beautiful, young Jewish women.

Stalin's close associates and loyalists included member of the Central Committee and Politburo Lazar Kaganovich. Montefiore characterizes him as the 'first Stalinist' and adds that those starving to death in Ukraine, an unparalleled tragedy in the history of human kind aside from the Nazi horrors and Mao's terror in China, did not move Kaganovich.

Many Jews sold their soul to the devil of the Communist revolution and have blood on their hands for eternity. We'll mention just one more: Leonid Reichman, head of the NKVD's special department and the organization's chief interrogator, who was a particularly cruel sadist.

In 1934, according to published statistics, 38.5 percent of those holding the most senior posts in the Soviet security apparatuses were of Jewish origin. They too, of course, were gradually eliminated in the next purges. In a fascinating lecture at a Tel Aviv University convention this week, Dr. Halfin described the waves of soviet terror as a 'carnival of mass murder', ' fantasy of purges', and ' essianism of evil'. Turns out that Jews too, when they become captivated by messianic ideology, can become great murderers, among the greatest known by modern history.

The Jews active in official communist terror apparatuses (In the Soviet Union and abroad) and who at times led them, did not do this, obviously, as Jews, but rather, as Stalinists, communists, and "Soviet people." Therefore, we find it easy to ignore their origin and 'play dumb': What do we have to do with them? But let's not forget them. My own view is different. I find it unacceptable that a person will be considered a member of the Jewish people when he does great things, but not considered part of our people when he does amazingly despicable things.

 

----------------------

Submitted by Alan Newark:
www.holocaustforgotten.com/search_51-127.htm
From: RSHK@aol.com
Roma Sonia Horodysky-Kowcznd is

My grandfather aided and hid Jews in Western Ukraine during the Second World War. I would like to know how one would go about searching for witnesses or people who were indeed helped by my grandfather in order to have my grandfather publicly recognized for his bravery by having his name included in The Righteous among Nations list.

I realize this search may be fruitless, due to the length of time that has elapsed between now and then.

He lived in Pomorjany, Brody (where he hid Jews in his home) and Lvov,all towns and cities in Ukraine. My aunt (his sister-in-law) is still living and could stand as one witness. My mother (his daughter) is also living and could stand as another witness. I know of three other people who knew of this and are also still living.

I do not know the names of the people he hid, but there may be someone who might remember his name. My grandfather was also a prisoner of war in the concentration camp at Bereza Kartuska. Do you know where I can get any additional information on this particular concentration camp (ie. names of prisoners, dates, pictures of the camp etc).

Any internet searches I have done have yielded very little information. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Thank you! With much gratitude.
       
Roma Sonia Horodysky-Kowcz

12/2/2011 Submitted by: Alan Newark braveheart562002@yahoo.com

http://forums.contractoruk.com/general/9494-england-owes-poland-immigrant-claims-4.html

The Western Ukrainian People's Republic (ZUNR), proclaimed on November 1, 1918 after a successful revolt of the ethnic Ukrainian elements of the Austro-Hungarian garrisons in Galicia, had a population of 6,2 mln (71% Ukrainians, 14% Poles, 13% Jews, and 2% Germans).

Whereas Polish minority launched an insurgency in Lviv, supported by the intervention from Poland, denying Ukrainian right for national statehood in Galicia, the Jewish community maintained a friendly neutrality, recognized the Ukrainian government and even participated in the armed struggle.

According to the existing contemporary reports, the Jewish population of such districts as Buchach, Rava-Russka, Rudky?Komarno and Olesk supported the Ukrainian revolt of November 1, 1918 immediately after it was successfully accomplished. In the town of Dolyna the local Jewish community even swore the oath of allegiance to the new Western Ukrainian state and declared its members the state citizens.

The Jewish youth in the city of Ternopil (provisional ZUNR capital) initiated the formation of a student battalion in the Ukrainian Galician Army in December 1918, known as the 1st Jewish Battalion, which, however, was not completed at the time. In November/December 1918 in Western Ukrainian cities and towns, where considerable Jewish communities traditionally settled, multi-party representative Jewish assemblies were called by the prominent Jewish leaders for closer cooperation with the Ukrainian authorities.

The Jewish National Councils were created in Ternopil, Drogobych, Stanislav, Stryj, Boryslav, Buchach, Kolomyja, Kalush, Chortkiv, Borshchiv, Burshtyn, Gvizdec, Gusiatyn, Zhydachuv, Zabolotiv, Zalishchyky, Kopychynci, Nadvirna, Otynia, Pidgajci, Snjatyn, Tysmenyca, and Tlumach.

In Peremyshl, where the control of the city was established by the Ukrainian troops on November 2?3, 1918, the confrontation with the Polish units began on November 4, so the Jewish community, sympathetic towards Ukrainians, established two representative bodies: the Civilian National Jewish Council and Military People's Jewish Council.

The latter controlled the Jewish militia unit, created from the personnel oif the 9th Infantry Regiment. Unfortunately, the outcome of the fighting on November 10-11, 1918 and the occupation of the city by Polish troops, brought the cooperation between Ukrainians and Jews in Peremyshl to an abrupt end.

Last edited by Clog II The Avenger; 14th August 2006 at 11:26.

A Documentation of Ukrainians who rescued Jews during the Holocaust

3 May 2010

Approached by Leonid Finberg of the Center for Studies of the History and Culture of East  European Jews, National University of “Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”, the UCRDC has agreed to collaborate on a project on Ukrainian-Jewish relations. Titled “I am my brother’s keeper”, the project involves both a research element and a public awareness campaign.

The UCRDC will focus on identifying and documenting cases that have a Canadian connection, and will undertake research in Canada to review what is already known, and covered by the media; locate and organize materials from the UCRDC archives and oral history collection; and conduct interviews in Canada regarding Ukrainians who hid or saved Jews during World War II.

The project has the support of the Ukrainian Jewish Encounter Initiative (UJEI), a privately organized, multinational initiative whose goal is to deepen scholarly and broader public understanding of the breadth, complexity, and diversity of Ukrainian-Jewish relations, with a view to the future. Canadians, including notably Jim Temerty, are playing an important role in the development and leadership of this initiative.

Once a number of significant cases have been documented, UJEI, UCRDC, and the Center for Studies of the History and Culture of East  European Jews in Kyiv will collaboratively organize events to raise awareness about these exceptional people and those saved by them.

The UCRDC would welcome any information that might be helpful in accomplishing this task – in particular, suggestions regarding people who should be interviewed in connection with their own experience or that of a family member.

Orest Zakydalsky, Researcher
Ukrainian Canadian Research and Documentation Centre
620 Spadina Ave.
Toronto, ON
M5S 2H4
Tel – 416-966-1819 (office)1/27/2012
Email – office@ucrdc.org
Submitted by Alan Newark       braveheart180203@hotmail.com Alan Newark

 


From: alan newark braveheart180203@hotmail.com
Date: Sun, 4 Nov 2012

Subject: Jewish-Ukrainian letters from www.kontakte-kontakty.de

Memories of Holocaust survivor Raja Nusinowna Archowa about her stay in the ghetto area in Tultschinsk Vinnitsa, Ukraine.


I, Raja Nusinowna Archowa, was born in 1931. My family: My father Nusin Moschkowitsch Scherb (b. 1900), my mother Ester Iojlowna (b. 1903) and brother Grigory Nusinowitsch Scherb (b. 1935).

On 22 June 1941 and the war on 22 July 1941 Tulchin was occupied by the Germans in Vinnitsa region. I was only ten years old. With horror I think back to those years.

First, the Germans came to our town. A few months later, they handed the management of the city to the Romanians, who were stooges of the German fascists. Right at the beginning of the occupation, the Jews were expelled from their homes, we lived in the suburbs, had to immediately wear the yellow star and we were forced to physical dirty work. They treated us like the last animals.

Several times, we paid Romanians the money -- thought we could save ourselves. but we were wrong. With each passing day, they treated us worse. In October 1941, all Jews were herded into the square. Most of them have been associated with a transport to the Pechersky District Tulchin. Tulchin remained with only 25 skilled workers who would work for the Romanians.

After the ghetto had been reduced so dramatically in Tulchin, we came to "Quarantine". The building in which we should live was half destroyed with smashed windows. We slept on the cement floor, warming each other. It was very tight in the small rooms, in each room 20-30 people, lived like sardines in a can. We had neither clothes nor food and were starving literally. We had lice, were sick, had fever and cough and which put us at each other.

That we have survived, we have to thank our Ukrainian friends alone who appreciated my father very much because he was a good tailor. They threw us boiled potatoes and bread over the fence.

Again and again we had to take to the parade to be checked, should not be whether someone was hiding from us, and we were so scared that our teeth were chattering loudly. If someone is moving in the series, they beat him before the eyes of the children. A month after the "quarantine" they drove us to the middle of the night Volodarsky Street. It was very dark and there were a burning campfire. Each family was looking for a shelter in this absolute darkness. The ghetto was guarded day and night by Polizai. There were repeated raids; they were looking for someone or something. We had no childhood.

With each passing day, the harassment and humiliation grew worse, ultimately they led us through even experiments with new drugs. It was said that we should get back to a certain point where we should get a shot, allegedly to prevent epidemics. We went all like willing children. After that we got rash all over the body and fever up to 40 degrees, which we tried to relieve with a cold compress. Something else to treat it, we did not have. Also, they drove us into the wash house where our clothes supposedly were disinfected. After that procedure, we all got lice and scabies.
These are examples that show how we were harassed and humiliated.
The occupation lasted for about two years and seven months.

On 03/15/1944 Tulchin was liberated by Soviet troops in the Vinnitsa region. So that our suffering was over.

Raja Nusiniwna Archowa.

Continue to page 3, Jews and Sheptyts'kyi (Sheptytski)
SLAVA UKRAYINI  ! HEROYAM SLAVA!!!!
Слава Украине! Слава героям слава!Слава Україні! Слава героям!
 translated as: Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!!!  is a Ukrainian greeting slogan being used now all over Ukraine to signify support for a free independent Ukraine

Offline JayH

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5685
  • Country: au
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Ukraine
  • Status: Looking > 5 years
  • Trips: > 10
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #2 on: December 19, 2013, 11:10:19 PM »
Metropolitan Sheptyts'kyi

Righteous indignation

By Yossi Melman and Asaf Carmel

Witness story: Snow has played a decisive role in the life of Lily Stern-Pohlmann. When she escaped from the Lvov ghetto she trudged through knee-high drifts of it, on a Ukrainian winter night, until she reached the hiding place and was reunited with her mother. Afterward, about a year later, in late 1943 or early 1944 (she doesn't remember the exact date), on another snowy night, she and her mother fled for their lives again. This time, they found shelter in the compound attached to the cathedral of Lvov, in the quarters of the metropolitan (a bishop with provincial powers). She was only 11 years-old then, but the memory has stayed with her for over 60 years.
"He was a huge and impressive man. Even though he was confined to a wheelchair, the most noticeable thing about him was his tremendous physical size. To me, as a little girl, he looked like a giant. He had a thick white beard and warm eyes," she recalls her first meeting with Andrei Sheptyts'kyi, speaking by telephone from her home in London. "I was very scared. He put his hands on my head and said with a smile: 'Welcome, don't be afraid. I will save your life.'"

And he kept his promise. A few months later, in the summer of 1944, the Red Army liberated the western provinces of Ukraine from Nazi occupation. Lily and her mother could stop hiding at last.

Over the past 50 years or so, Lily, her mother (who has since died) and a group of other Holocaust survivors and relatives, including Adam Rotfeld, currently the Polish foreign minister, have been trying to persuade the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial authority in Jerusalem to confer on the Ukrainian priest Andrei Sheptyts'kyi the title of "Righteous Among the Nations." But in vain. Aside from the persistent efforts of these survivors and a few brief mentions in history books, the story of Sheptyts'kyi has been consigned to oblivion. Nor was Yad Vashem moved by an article about him that was published in Maariv on the most recent Holocaust Day four months ago.

The Problem:This is not just an argument about memory, forgetting and commemoration. In the backdrop, there is also a stinging debate about historical interpretation and historical "truth." On one side are the personal truths and histories of each one of the survivors. And on the other: the truth as proclaimed by Yad Vashem, holder of the legal authority to grant the title, which views itself as the final arbiter on Holocaust history. The survivors are convinced that their own motives are pure and noble, while those of Yad Vashem, in their estimation, are also influenced by political and bureaucratic considerations. It is also a battle over time. As the passing years continue to cull the number of survivors, the phenomenon of forgetting history only gains momentum. With this in mind, the survivors are all the more determined to make their case.

In recent weeks, a small group has taken up its struggle anew. This time, they are being assisted by Prof. Shimon Redlich of Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, a historian and expert on Eastern European Jewry. They are currently formulating a petition on which they aim to collect the signatures of other Holocaust survivors and public figures; the petition will then be sent to Yad Vashem along with a call for the institution to reconsider its position. In early November, the Ukrainian-Jewish organization Tkuma will hold a seminar in Lvov, with the participation of historians from Israel and the Ukraine, in appreciation of Sheptyts'kyi and his contribution to the Jewish people. But most of all, the Holocaust survivors and supporters of their struggle are drawing encouragement from the planned visit to Israel - in about two months - by Ukrainian president Victor Yushchenko, and are hopeful that the Foreign Ministry's attitude will also help: In the ministry, they're aware that the granting of this title to someone who is considered a national hero in the Ukraine could give a boost to relations between the two countries.

Biography: Roman Sheptyts'kyi was born in 1865 to a Ukrainian noble family whose family tree could be traced as far back as the 13th century. Over the generations and living under Polish occupation, the family underwent a process of assimilation and adopted Polish customs, values and culture. When Sheptyts'kyi was a young man, Ukraine was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire and he was drawn to the Ukrainian national movement, which sought to establish an independent state. He also expressed a desire to become a priest. Instead, his parents sent him to Germany to study law. Although he graduated with outstanding marks, instead of embarking on a legal career, he remained steadfast in his desire to join the priesthood.

When he finished his studies, in 1888, the young Sheptyts'kyi decided to travel to Italy, to see Pope Leon XIII and to consult with him about his future. He subsequently abandoned the Catholic Church for the Greek Catholic (Uniatic) Church, changed his first name from Roman to Andrei and began studying in a seminary for priests. The Uniatic Church was founded in 1596, when Ukraine was under Polish-Catholic rule: It preserved the Byzantine ceremonies and rituals, but recognized the pope as its ultimate authority. In Russia, it was dismantled by the czarist government and combined with the Pravoslavic Church, though it continued to exist in the western provinces of Ukraine, which were under the Austro-Hungarian regime. This is still its center of power and it has between five and six million faithful today.

Sheptyts'kyi's rise within the church was meteoric and in 1900, at the age of 35, he was invested with the title of metropolitan and appointed head of the Church, a position he held until his death. In the history of Ukraine, his name is connected with the revival of the Church in western Ukraine in the first half of the 20th century. In 1903, Sheptyts'kyi founded the Studite monastic order, which built schools, orphanages and hospitals. These monasteries would later play an important role in saving Jews. Sheptyts'kyi also persuaded his brother, Kazimierz, a lawyer and member of the Austrian parliament who shared his nationalistic views, to give up his worldly pursuits and join the priesthood. Kazimierz changed his name to Clement and was appointed head of the Studite order.

In his early years in the Church, when he was just 20, Andrei Sheptyts'kyi began studying Hebrew and before long he was able to read the Bible in that language. Years later, he took pride in an exchange of letters with leaders of Jewish communities, written in elegant biblical Hebrew. In 1905 and 1906, he headed a group of pilgrims that visited the Holy Land. After his second visit, he wrote a religious guide book that included a description of pilgrimage routes, complete with maps and illustrations.

His study of the Hebrew language spurred the metropolitan to want to get to know Jews up close. "Acquaintance with Jews and with Judaism was an integral part of the intellectual and practical environment of Sheptyts'kyi," says Prof. Shimon Redlich, author of the book, "Together and Apart in Brzezany: Poles, Jews and Ukrainians, 1919-1945" (Indiana University Press, 2002). His special attitude toward the Jews was made manifest over the years in numerous friendly get-togethers with community rabbis. The greetings exchanged at these events were primarily in Hebrew. The very occurrence of such meetings was no trivial matter in a land where anti-Semitism was deeply ingrained. In his book, "Lvov Ghetto Diary," Dr. David Kahana (one of the people the metropolitan saved during the Holocaust), describes how Sheptyts'kyi prided himself on taking part in the kimha-depisha (alms for the poor) projects in his area before each Passover holiday.

When he turned 70, in 1935, a Jewish daily newspaper published a special congratulatory message from the Lvov Jewish community, praising the metropolitan for his high level of ethics and morals. The chief rabbi of Lvov's Reform community, Rabbi Dr. Ezekiel Lewin (whose two sons, Kurt and Nathan, were also later saved thanks to Sheptyts'kyi's actions) held a special reception in his honor.

Sheptyts'kyi also supported the Zionist settlement in the Land of Israel and expressed his enthusiastic opinion of it in a 1934 interview with Lieber Krumholz, a young Jewish journalist who later immigrated to Israel, changed his name to Haviv and was a member of the Haaretz editorial board for many years. Yet it must also be borne in mind that Sheptyts'kyi's attitude toward the Jews was motivated by his theological outlook and a missionary aspiration. "When I stand before a Jewish audience that is willing to hear me," he explained in one of his sermons, "I can't help but see them as people who are exposed to eternal devastation. This is why I see it as my duty to use the opportunity to bring them at least a single word of the divine revelation."

The head of the Uniatic Church was first and foremost a Ukrainian patriot, who as early as 1905 built a Ukrainian national museum and supported the establishment of an independent Ukrainian state. In World War I, when Russia conquered Lvov, Sheptyts'kyi was imprisoned for two years. After the war, he returned to Lvov, which had now been annexed to Poland. In 1923, his younger brother Stanislaw, a general in the Polish army, was appointed the defense minister of Poland, but he himself, and his Church as an organization, formed close ties with the Ukrainian national movement.

It was natural for him to oppose the Soviet Union, which controlled a large part of Ukraine, because of the communist regime and Stalin's anti-religious policies. The resistance to the Soviet Union grew when Lvov was occupied by it in 1939 and came under Soviet rule for about two years. When the German army invaded the Soviet Union in 1941, he cheered it on in the hope that it meant the dream of Ukrainian independence would now be fulfilled. In a letter "To the Ukrainian Nation," the metropolitan proclaimed: "We see the German army as the savior from the enemy."

But at the same time, as Rabbi Kahana writes in his book, Sheptyts'kyi also did not hesitate to compose a "shepherds' letter" in which he called on the new government to issue directives and rules that would ensure the welfare of all inhabitants of the land, without regard to faith, nationality or social class. Kahana is convinced that the metropolitan was referring to the Jews. And this was written at a time when SS units, with the assistance of auxiliary Ukrainian [which had a majority of Dutch members and totally controlled by Germany] units, had already begun massacring Jews. Heinrich Himmler, the SS commander, heard about the letter and ordered Sheptyts'kyi arrested, but the German commander in Lvov informed him that such a move would arouse the fury of Ukrainians, for whom this clergyman was a national hero, and could thus pose a danger to the German army. Himmler was persuaded and withdrew his demand.

Later on, in February 1942, the metropolitan sent a direct letter to Himmler in which he demanded that all Ukrainian police officers be removed from all the actions involving killings of Jews. In his letter, he denounced the Germans' treatment of the Ukrainian population, and of the Jews in particular, and protested the use of Ukrainian police in actions against the Jews. In his letter to Himmler, Sheptyts'kyi wrote that the Ukrainian was basically a primitive human being and would eventually do to his own people what he did to the Jews, that he was becoming accustomed to murder and would not easily be weaned from it.

According to Prof. Redlich's research, "at least three people (one of them was Rabbi Kahana) testified that they saw Sheptyts'kyi's letter to Himmler. However, the original cannot be obtained, nor can any copy of it." Afterward, the metropolitan published his famous "shepherds' letter" under the heading "Thou Shalt Not Kill," and in March, 1942 sent a letter to Pope Pius XII in which he warned about the murder of the Jews at the hands of the Germans and their Ukrainian minions. In another letter to the Vatican, from August, 1942, which was written in the shadow of the aktzias of that month, in which about 50,000 Jews from the Lvov ghetto were sent to their deaths, he spoke out against the Nazi regime: "When we were liberated by the German army from the Bolshevik burden we felt a certain relief. Now everyone agrees that the German regime is perhaps worse and more evil than the Bolshevik one." He also conveyed directives to the people of his sect to hide Jews in churches, monasteries and orphanages in order to save them from the genocide. And, in this, he also set a personal example.

For more, see:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=632512&contrassID=19

--------------

The reason why Archbishop Sheptitsky has not (yet) been honored with Righteous Gentile award:

Turned down after consideration by Yad Vashem’s Commission for the Designation of the Righteous Among the Nations (the commission convenes more than 20 times each year in closed sessions) more than a dozen times since 1964, Metropolitan Sheptitsky remains arguably Yad Vashem’s most difficult case. While no one denies that he was responsible for the rescue of many Jews, his critics point to many factors that have made him ineligible to be named a Righteous Gentile: as Ukraine’s highest-ranking cleric, he putatively faced no personal danger for opposing the Germans’ Final Solution; as the acknowledged leader of the wartime Ukrainian nationalist movement, he originally welcomed the Nazis, seeing them as a means to Ukrainian independence; as the head of the Uniate church, he gave his blessings to the formation of two Ukrainian SS divisions; as a man with longtime sympathetic relations to the Jewish community, he did not proactively seek out Jews to assist but did open his church’s doors to people who approached him.

For more of the story, see:

http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/international-news/righteous-gentile-or-nazi-supporter

Submitted by: Lavrentiy

------------------
SLAVA UKRAYINI  ! HEROYAM SLAVA!!!!
Слава Украине! Слава героям слава!Слава Україні! Слава героям!
 translated as: Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!!!  is a Ukrainian greeting slogan being used now all over Ukraine to signify support for a free independent Ukraine

Offline JayH

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5685
  • Country: au
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Ukraine
  • Status: Looking > 5 years
  • Trips: > 10
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #3 on: December 20, 2013, 07:05:40 PM »
A lot of Ukrainian history that is relevant today is covered  here and in the links-very interesting reading.
SLAVA UKRAYINI  ! HEROYAM SLAVA!!!!
Слава Украине! Слава героям слава!Слава Україні! Слава героям!
 translated as: Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!!!  is a Ukrainian greeting slogan being used now all over Ukraine to signify support for a free independent Ukraine

Offline Boethius

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3114
  • Country: 00
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: No Selection
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #4 on: December 20, 2013, 07:07:57 PM »
Some is no longer accurate.  Since the collapse of the USSR, archives have proven that UPA was involved in the first L'viv pogrom, though they were not the instigators.  They did round up Jews for the Germans, though.


Also, Trotsky was the architect of collectivization.  Kaganovich was the henchman.
« Last Edit: January 07, 2014, 03:44:29 AM by AnonMod »
After the fall of communism, the biggest mistake Boris Yeltsin's regime made was not to disband the KGB altogether. Instead it changed its name to the FSB and, to many observers, morphed into a gangster organisation, eventually headed by master criminal Vladimir Putin. - Gerard Batten

Offline Boethius

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3114
  • Country: 00
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: No Selection
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #5 on: December 21, 2013, 03:07:19 PM »
Quote
Ukrainians were the only group that was committing suicide rather than be deported back to USSR as per the Yalta agreement population exchange.

Untrue.  The Cossacks also committed suicide.  I knew DP's who saw Cossack mothers drown their children, then themselves, or jump off bridges.

DP's under American control usually did not suffer this fate, as sympathetic Americans would tell them to identify themselves as Poles. 

Also, I believe Belarussians had the highest level of civilian deaths in WWII - one in every four Belarussians died - and the lowest level of collaboration.
After the fall of communism, the biggest mistake Boris Yeltsin's regime made was not to disband the KGB altogether. Instead it changed its name to the FSB and, to many observers, morphed into a gangster organisation, eventually headed by master criminal Vladimir Putin. - Gerard Batten

Offline mendeleyev

  • RWD Advisor
  • *****
  • Posts: 5670
  • Country: ua
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: Resident
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #6 on: December 21, 2013, 03:59:10 PM »
Quote
Throughout his book, Bauer targets the Ukrainians as co-conspirators to the Nazis. In actual numbers, Ukrainians were far greater victims than were the Jews in World War II

Many Ukrainians were co-conspirators for two reasons:

- Get rid of the Communists.

- Get rid of the Jews, who many Ukrainians say as usurpers.

This author is attempting to revise history.
The Mendeleyev Journal. http://mendeleyevjournal.com Member: Congress of Russian Journalists; ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.RU (Journalist-Russia); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.UA (Journalist-Ukraine); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.KZ (Journalist-Kazakhstan); ПОРТАЛ ЖУРНАЛИСТОВ (Portal of RU-UA Journalists); Просто Журналисты ("Just Journalists").

Offline Boethius

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3114
  • Country: 00
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: No Selection
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #7 on: December 21, 2013, 05:48:59 PM »
Many Ukrainians were co-conspirators for two reasons:

- Get rid of the Communists.

- Get rid of the Jews, who many Ukrainians say as usurpers.

This author is attempting to revise history.


I disagree with you.  Ukrainian collaboration in WWII was no higher than in any other occupied country.  In villages, Jews were usually killed within the first few days of Germans sweeping in.  In towns, they were easily identifiable, as they spoke differently and often, dressed differently, at least, in Western Ukraine.
After the fall of communism, the biggest mistake Boris Yeltsin's regime made was not to disband the KGB altogether. Instead it changed its name to the FSB and, to many observers, morphed into a gangster organisation, eventually headed by master criminal Vladimir Putin. - Gerard Batten

Offline JayH

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5685
  • Country: au
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: Ukraine
  • Status: Looking > 5 years
  • Trips: > 10
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #8 on: December 21, 2013, 06:21:27 PM »
Many Ukrainians were co-conspirators for two reasons:

- Get rid of the Communists.

- Get rid of the Jews, who many Ukrainians say as usurpers.

This author is attempting to revise history.

History and actions of individuals is always open to interpretation. The problem arises when interpretation is designed to bend the conclusions reached to suit a specific point of view.
SLAVA UKRAYINI  ! HEROYAM SLAVA!!!!
Слава Украине! Слава героям слава!Слава Україні! Слава героям!
 translated as: Glory to Ukraine! Glory to the heroes!!!  is a Ukrainian greeting slogan being used now all over Ukraine to signify support for a free independent Ukraine

Offline mendeleyev

  • RWD Advisor
  • *****
  • Posts: 5670
  • Country: ua
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: Resident
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #9 on: December 21, 2013, 06:28:54 PM »
Both of you have valid points however in the case of Kyiv it might seems as if the Jewish population lasted longer but there is no question that many Jewish farms, homes, etc, were of great interest to certain Ukrainians during that time.

The Mendeleyev Journal. http://mendeleyevjournal.com Member: Congress of Russian Journalists; ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.RU (Journalist-Russia); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.UA (Journalist-Ukraine); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.KZ (Journalist-Kazakhstan); ПОРТАЛ ЖУРНАЛИСТОВ (Portal of RU-UA Journalists); Просто Журналисты ("Just Journalists").

Offline Boethius

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3114
  • Country: 00
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: No Selection
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #10 on: December 21, 2013, 06:33:53 PM »
In Western Ukrainian cities, "Jew" meant "communist", mostly because the NKVD there were predominantly Jewish.

The property of Ukrainian Jews was confiscated by the Germans.  Their homes and apartments were sealed.  Looting, whether  by locals or German soldiers, was not tolerated.  Looters and thieves were hanged, their bodies displayed publicly.
« Last Edit: December 21, 2013, 07:24:36 PM by Boethius »
After the fall of communism, the biggest mistake Boris Yeltsin's regime made was not to disband the KGB altogether. Instead it changed its name to the FSB and, to many observers, morphed into a gangster organisation, eventually headed by master criminal Vladimir Putin. - Gerard Batten

Offline mendeleyev

  • RWD Advisor
  • *****
  • Posts: 5670
  • Country: ua
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: Resident
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #11 on: December 21, 2013, 08:03:55 PM »
Very true, Bo, but that was once the Germans had arrived and established "order."
The Mendeleyev Journal. http://mendeleyevjournal.com Member: Congress of Russian Journalists; ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.RU (Journalist-Russia); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.UA (Journalist-Ukraine); ЖУРНАЛИСТЫ.KZ (Journalist-Kazakhstan); ПОРТАЛ ЖУРНАЛИСТОВ (Portal of RU-UA Journalists); Просто Журналисты ("Just Journalists").

Offline Boethius

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3114
  • Country: 00
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: No Selection
  • Trips: No Selection
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #12 on: December 21, 2013, 08:53:48 PM »
There were no communists or Jews killed, AFAIK, by Ukrainians in the interwar period before Operation Barbarossa.
After the fall of communism, the biggest mistake Boris Yeltsin's regime made was not to disband the KGB altogether. Instead it changed its name to the FSB and, to many observers, morphed into a gangster organisation, eventually headed by master criminal Vladimir Putin. - Gerard Batten

Offline Slumba

  • Banned Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1462
  • Country: us
  • Gender: Male
  • Spouse's Country: No Selection
  • Status: Looking 1-2 years
  • Trips: 1 - 3
Re: Efforts To Reconcile Jewish and Ukrainian people
« Reply #13 on: December 21, 2013, 10:49:54 PM »
Is it the case that:

1. 80% of the first Politburo was Jewish? 

2. Many of the people in Ukraine who supported speaking Russian over Ukrainian were Jews?

Might account for some of the bad feeling ... I don't know, that is why I ask.  Supposedly Putin mentioned #1 in passing recently... of course Karl Marx was Jewish, and many of his supporters , including the prominent rabbi Stephen Wise in the USA, were sympathetic to Marxism.
Me gusta ir de compras con mi tarjeta verde...

 

+-RWD Stats

Members
Total Members: 8888
Latest: UA2006
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 545824
Total Topics: 20967
Most Online Today: 7502
Most Online Ever: 12701
(January 14, 2020, 07:04:55 AM)
Users Online
Members: 8
Guests: 7491
Total: 7499

+-Recent Posts

Re: A Wallet on Legs? by Boethius
Today at 08:53:08 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by krimster2
Today at 04:34:07 PM

Re: Christian Orthodox Family by Trenchcoat
Today at 04:33:16 PM

Re: Christian Orthodox Family by Trenchcoat
Today at 04:12:42 PM

Re: The Struggle For Ukraine by Trenchcoat
Today at 04:00:10 PM

Re: The fiance's B-day by krimster2
Today at 03:27:52 PM

Re: Operation White Panther by krimster2
Today at 02:03:52 PM

Re: Operation White Panther by Patagonie
Today at 01:22:41 PM

Re: A Wallet on Legs? by krimster2
Today at 01:09:00 PM

Re: Operation White Panther by Patagonie
Today at 12:46:58 PM

Powered by EzPortal